Wittgenstein’s Context Principle Essay

2542 words - 10 pages

In his Tractatus Logico Philosophicus, Ludwig Wittgenstein makes the following claim “…only in the nexus of a proposition does a name have meaning” (TLP 3.3). This claim is a version of what has come to be known in the literature as the context principle and is taken to assert simply that a word has meaning only when it is within a sentence. An intuitive objection to this principle is that it conflicts with a trait of language called compositionality. Compositionality describes the ability we possess to form new sentences, with new meanings, using familiar words. This is the characteristic of language that Wittgenstein is clearly alluding to when he tells us that “A proposition must use old expressions to communicate a new sense” (TLP 4.03). The conflict between compositionality and the context principle is the matter of how we are able to form meaningful sentences out of words when words, when they stand on their own, do not have any meaning. Since Wittgenstein asserts a version of the context principle while acknowledging compositionality, it would seem that he is holding on to a problematic account of meaning.
In this paper I will explain why Wittgenstein claims statement 3.3, and show that it is in fact possible to maintain his context principle in light of compositionality. I will argue that this statement is entailed by Wittgenstein’s account of meaningful propositions as pictures of facts. We will see that names are only meaningful thanks to the position they occupy in a proposition thus rendering names meaningless when they appear on their own. In light of this account it is evident that completely isolated names could not be used to form new propositions since the former lack meaning. This is the apparent clash with compositionality. However, I will argue that we can form new propositions with familiar names once we have seen how they behave within a proposition. In fact, we will see that not only does compositionality not conflict with statement 3.3, but that our ability to form meaningful propositions with familiar expressions and to determine which propositions are not meaningful constitutes evidence for Wittgenstein’s context principle.
The context principle was first articulated by Gotlob Frege in his Foundations of Arithmetic as the imperative that one should not attempt to determine the meaning of an isolated word but only do so in the context of a proposition. Frege’s motivation in introducing the context principle is to explain our use of numbers and to account for the fact that we can entertain thoughts containing numeric terms. In this essay, I will not elaborate Frege’s development of this idea. For my purpose it will suffice to note that Frege's choice of words indicates that the context principle is first and foremost intended as a methodological principle- a maxim one ought to abide by when going about the analysis of a meaning of a word. It is possible to adhere to Frege’s version of the context principle while...

Find Another Essay On Wittgenstein’s Context Principle

phase diagram Essay

4456 words - 18 pages Introduction: Chemical equilibrium is a crucial topic in Chemistry. To represent and model equilibrium, the thermodynamic concept of Free energy is usually used. For a multi-component system the Gibbs free energy is a function of Pressure, Temperature and quantity (mass, moles) of each component. If one of these parameters is changed, a state change to a more energetically favorable state will occur. This state has the lowest free energy

Revolutionary Work of Art Essay

1890 words - 8 pages Walter Benjamin emphasizes in his essay, “The Work of Art in the Age of its Technological Reproducibility” that technology used to make an artwork has changed the way it was received, and its “aura”. Aura represents the originality and authenticity of a work of art that has not been reproduced. The Sistine Chapel in the Vatican is an example of a work that has been and truly a beacon of art. It has brought a benefit and enlightenment to the art

Enlightenment Thought in New Zealand Schools

1594 words - 6 pages right to use their own judgment and reasoning not just accepting what others say and whet they are told. Kramnick (1995) stated that enlightenment intellectuals believed “human reason, not faith or tradition was the principle to human conduct.” (Kramnick, 1995, p.xi). This focus on the individual is summed up by Kant (1995, p.1) said “Have courage to use your own reason.” This in other worlds is telling people to think for themselves. With the

Psychological Egoism Theory

2240 words - 9 pages The theory of psychological egoism is indeed plausible. The meaning of plausible in the context of this paper refers to the validity or the conceivability of the theory in question, to explain the nature and motivation of human behavior (Hinman, 2007). Human actions are motivated by the satisfaction obtained after completing a task that they are involved in. For example, Mother Teresa was satisfied by her benevolent actions and

How Celtic Folkore has Influenced My Family

1587 words - 6 pages Every family has a unique background that influences the way they live and interact with other people. My parents, who emigrated from Ireland to the States with my three brothers in 1989, brought over their own Celtic folklore and traditions that have helped shaped the way our family operates and lives. One aspect of folklore that has helped shape my family dynamic is the Celtic cross—both its background and what role it has played in our lives

Julia Margaret Cameron

1406 words - 6 pages At a time when women were looked upon as being homemakers, wives, mothers and such the late 1850's presented a change in pace for one woman in specific. Photography was discovered in 1826 and soon after the phenomenon of photography was being experimented with and in turn brought new and different ways of photo taking not only as documenting real time, but also conceptualizing a scene in which an image would be taken. Julia Margaret Cameron will

Evaluation of School Improvement

1403 words - 6 pages The evaluation process should be progressive to incorporate overall planning, implement changes, which contribute to success. In order to focus on school climate and norms, the evaluation design must include the students, instructions, and outcomes to improve communication and building-level concerns to be address in this response. School Climate and Social Norms The school principal, other staff leaders, and personnel set the tone and the

Case Study: The Benefits of Animal Testing

1757 words - 7 pages Nine year old Amy has already had a rough start in life. She was born with an abnormal heart that hinders her everyday activities. Amy is unable to keep up with kids her own age because she often tires out easily. As a consequence, she has very little friends and is often alone. Amy is forced to take different medications everyday just to survive. Amy’s life consists of medicine, doctors, and constant hospital visits. However, Amy is due for a

Myth and Magic: Realism in "One Hundred Years of Solitude"

1531 words - 6 pages “He enjoyed his grandmother's unique way of telling stories. No matter how fantastic or improbable her statements, she always delivered them as if they were the irrefutable truth” (Wikipedia, 2011). Experiences are particular instances of one personally encountering or undergoing something and in these moments of time life changes for the best or the worst and memories are formed. These recollections such as riding your first bicycle, going to

Adiponectin: a Novel Indicator of Malnutrition and Inflammation in Hemodialysis Patients

2384 words - 10 pages ones. Furthermore, weak but statistically significant positive correlations were found between serum levels of adiponectin and SGA and MIS scores. Inflammation and malnutrition are two main components in the context of MICS in hemodialysis patients (1). The overlap between these two components creates an intricate clinical status on the basis of a vicious cycle in which inflammation and malnutrition could trigger each other in a mutual manner

The Congo Free State: A Legacy of Apathy, Exploitation and Brutality

2298 words - 9 pages II was “An ambitious, greedy, and devious monarch” whose “Principle aim … was to amass as large a fortune for himself as possible.” Meredith also quotes Joseph Conrad, who described the Congo Free State “As ‘the vilest scramble for loot that ever disfigured the history of human conscience.’” Yet, there are some scholars and officials who support Leopold II and the Congo Free State. Upon independence, The Belgian king, Baudouin I, stated that

Similar Essays

Cantor's Diagonal Argument Essay

1374 words - 5 pages this statement in accordance with the transfinite numbers. In his Remarks on the Foundation of Mathematics, Wittgenstein noted that whilst Cantor may say 2^(ℵ_0 )>ℵ_0 it is “a piece of mathematical architecture which hangs in the air, and looks as if it were, let us say, an architrave, but not supported by anything and supporting nothing” . Although we may consider Cantor’s theorem, it in fact does not inform us as to the context of 2^(ℵ_0 ). Hence

Wittgenstein And The Grammar “Pain” And The Approach To The Private Language Argument

1750 words - 7 pages is a private language? A private language as philosophers have used it is a different language as one might record in a diary and kept private from the others. A private language is in principle unintelligible to anyone but the linguist. The vocabulary of the private language is inaccessible to anyone but the linguist or subject. The idea of a private language in the sense had a philosophical appeal throughout the history of Western thought. A

It’s All In The Mind Essay

2585 words - 10 pages mental event causing a physical event. The method used is to say that events take place in a specific context. For example, I am enjoying a meal and I experience the desire for a glass of wine. The thought causes me to raise my arm to reach for the bottle. Of course, the sight of the wine could have caused the reaching out of the arm. In this case, it could be seen as an example of physical causation. The mental event could have been traced back

When The Bubble Burst Essay

1539 words - 6 pages By the time I arrived state side from my second tour in the Middle East the housing bubble had already burst. I noticed a drastic change in the way that many of my friends and family were living. Several of my friends that worked in real estate had sold their boats and seconds houses. My own stock portfolio had lost a third of its value. My sister and her husband had defaulted on their home mortgage leaving them scrambling for a place to live. I