This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Women In Combat Essay

2017 words - 8 pages

“In a perfect world, every U.S. soldier would be an asexual brute with a stunningly high IQ who doesn't eat much, is adept at following orders and leery of challenging authority” (Thompson). As far as humankind is concerned, there have never been any soldiers like that anywhere in the world, let alone the United States military. Therefore, the standards for enlisting in military combat positions are as high as possible to ensure that we can create soldiers that are effective as these “perfect-world” soldiers. There are obviously men and women who are not able to meet these standards, but there are definitely also men and women who are highly capable of meeting and/or exceeding these standards. While some individuals feel that the biological differences between men and women in combat would put our military at a disadvantage, evidence and logic prove that they are misinformed. Women in combat are able to fulfill many front line jobs already, are not at any higher risk of death than living a civilian life at home, and have the right to fight at the same level as their counterparts if they are capable of meeting the standards for battle.
Nonetheless, there are still individuals who insist that women do not belong on the front lines. Former Army Ranger, Roger Chapman, argues that “it’s about winning a war, not providing an opportunity. At the end of the day it's about national security" (Musgrave). He believes that letting women participate in combat is not practical for our military and could ultimately be a disadvantage. Others add that the addition of women to the battlefront would cause the standards for soldiers to be “gender-neutral” being that they have a different body type. A report from the Congressional Research stated that gender-neutral standards based on the amount of energy exerted would do no good to a female. This is due to the fact that even if a female exerts the same amount of energy carrying a seventy pound pack as a male carrying a hundred pound pack, it is not going to benefit her when she has to carry a hundred pound pack in the real world resulting in the task becoming too difficult for her to handle (Thompson). The definition of “gender-neutral” has a different definition for everyone and it does not necessarily mean energy exertion. These neutral standards are carefully put together to ensure that the soldier will be successful in battle. Moreover, combat depends on the person, not the gender. If a five foot tall, ninety-five pound man wants to enlist in a combat position, he is permitted to at least try. If he is able to complete the tasks, he is allowed to fight. Then why should a six foot tall, one hundred-eighty pound woman not be able to do the same? If the woman has the ability to carry the necessary load and complete the necessary tasks, it is logical to allow her on the battlefront with the rest of the competent men. The women who are looking for combat positions are not worried about their feelings or what is...

Find Another Essay On Women in Combat

Women In Combat Essay

813 words - 3 pages The idea of women in combat is not uncommon anymore. Women should be able to hold combat positions, although physical and mental strength matter, the military needs women, the intelligence and thinking they bring is very helpful. Banning women from combat, hurts their careers. Even though only a small percent of women enlist themselves, they are still a major part in the armed forces. Performance from these women has generated an extreme amount

Women in Combat Essay

1202 words - 5 pages      Women in Front Line Combat When it comes to combat assignments and the needs of the military, men take precedence over all other considerations, including career prospects of female service members. Female military members have been encouraged to pursue opportunities and career enhancement within the armed forces, which limit them only to the needs and good of the service due to women being not as “similarly

no women in combat

760 words - 4 pages a level of strength or endurance that could only be satisfied by a man, or a very small percentage of women, and even then not to the fullest level of completion. A true warrior understands his/her strengths and weaknesses, and as such, we should realize that women are a vital component in our military, although not in combat, and we should utilize them where they will be more profitable for the outcome of any given mission

Women in Ground-Combat Units

793 words - 4 pages On January 3, 2013 women were being considered for roles in ground-combat operations, causing a debate, can women effectively participate in combat? Some men and women are ready for the change and feel women can do anything a man can do. Others feel that it will affect unit cohesion and morale. Training standards being lowered to allow women to join more elite combat groups is another concern. Many people think women joining ground-combat

Should Women Serve In Combat?

843 words - 4 pages are needing women in a lot of job outside their home as men. Sadly, when we came to combat sector, we stop thinking logically. It is men major one hundred percent . If we look to the book (1001 things everyone should know about women's history) which written by Constance Jones (2000) we can find that only 88013 women among history had the ability to take part in military by give a variety of services. Some country actually these day try to make it

Women in combat why not?

1101 words - 4 pages The reality is that there is absolutely no intelligent, logical, sensible reason for women not to be in combat roles with the technological style of warfare that abounds today.There are political, patriarchal, religious, and misogynistically stupid reasons to preclude women but they all belong in The Museum of Natural Idiocy next to chastity belts, urban legends, homophobia, promise creepers, senile senators, proselytizing preachers, and

The Breakdown of Women in Combat Situations

1269 words - 5 pages ). Feminists believe there are women that can meet the standards. Yet, there is much wasted time training one hundred women for a mission, and coming out with only one to meet the minimum requirements (144). Most equipment weighs sixty to eighty pounds. This causes women to move much slower than men and reduces combat attack (141). There is no logic to put physically weaker comrades on the ground (144). When the going gets tough in combat, men will

Women Being Included in Military Combat

705 words - 3 pages also pick up how to handle different situation, working under pressure and resolving dilemmas. Women have risked their lives and died in America’s wars. They have dealt with lethal ammunition and operated urbane systems, while being in charge of both women and men in combat. Once women meet the physical and mental criteria, they are proficient, trained war fighters and leaders. For military assignments and duties, based on the training

Women Serving in Combat Roles in the Military

1889 words - 8 pages women are capable of meeting the demands of war, having served in numerous combat and combat-support positions. Mary Hays McCauley, also known as Molly Pitcher, fought in the Revolutionary War, taking over her husband's cannon duties after he was wounded. Margaret Corbin also fought in the Revolutionary War during the Battle of Fort Washington. During the Civil War, thousand of women served in both the Union and the Confederate armies

The Pro's and the Con's of Women Serving in Combat

1182 words - 5 pages Sue WaggonerProfessor KeeneEnglish 130216 September 2003The Pro's and the Con's of Women Serving in CombatWhether or not women should be allowed in combat is a question that rests in the minds of many Americans today. Although women are allowed to serve in the military they are still not allowed to serve in combat; why is that? Is it because today women are still not viewed as equal adversaries? These days and times, what exactly is combat? Is

Why Women Should Not Be Allowed In Combat Occupations?

1502 words - 7 pages Since 1901, women have been serving in some form of the military officially, however, women had an unofficial role dating back to the American Revolution. Traditionally women have not been allowed in combat occupations but recently these restrictions have been somewhat lifted, making certain combat occupations in most branches of the military available to women. Despite the lift complications arise from women being in combat occupations and

Similar Essays

Women In Combat Essay

1248 words - 5 pages Women in Combat      Women have played a tremendous role in many countries' armed forces from the past to the present. Women have thoroughly integrated into the armed forces; all positions in the armed forces should be fully accessible to women who can compete with men intellectually and physically. Yet, many argue that the distinction between combat and non-combat becomes blurred in the context of women warfare (Ladin; Holm, Hoar). In

Women In Combat Essay

2916 words - 12 pages By: Jery Carr In this report, I will present the information I've discovered concerning whether allowing women to serve in combat units will reduce a units effectiveness. Women in today's military serve in more jobs and constitute the largest percent of women in the military they ever have. Four years ago women only made up 12 percent of the military, this has climbed from 1.6 percent in 1973 (Armed Forces and Society, 1996, p. 17). They also

Women In Combat Essay

2160 words - 9 pages In the United States military combat units at battalion level and below have always been closed to women. However, change has been building up over the past decade on opening those closed positions and the Pentagon has decided to officially allow women on the front lines. Defense Secretary Leon E. Panetta lifted the Defense Department's ban on women in direct ground combat roles January 24, 2013 and on January 1, 2016 women will be able to

Women In Combat Essay

845 words - 3 pages Integration Act of 1948. This bill allowed women, for the first time, to pursue careers in the military. However, this also imposed several restrictions including what is now known as the combat exclusion laws; including the prohibition of women to serve on aircraft or ships involved in combat missions. The maintenance or repeal of the exclusion is a highly debated topic.One of the problems seems to be directly in the wording of the restriction: "Women