Women In Science Essay

1106 words - 5 pages

Opening Question: Can stereotypes and other biases interfere with scientific research?

When presented with the idea of science and experiments, the first thing that likely comes to mind is statistics and factual evidence. While these aspects are a major part of science, the subject is not solely based on them. To reach a sound conclusion, scientists must make inferences whether they are vague or detailed. According to Stephen Jay Gould, however, even the most respected scientists sometimes forget this key fact. In Gould’s essay, “Women’s Brains,” he argues that societal biases can infiltrate scientific fields and consequently create a plethora of issues. Gould utilizes comparison and contrast, a hyperbole, and strong diction to strongly develop his argument for his audience, intellectuals within the world.

Core Question 1: What is the purpose of comparing and contrasting several scientists within small excerpts?

Throughout his entire essay, Gould includes examples of several scientists’ thinking. The manner in which he lists these excerpts compares and contrasts each of them. These comparisons and contrasts build a foundation for the argument and show how even well-respected scientists can make mistakes. The first noted scientist is Paul Broca, a professor of clinical surgery. He states, “His numbers are sound. But science is an inferential exercise, not a catalog of fasts.” This shows that Paul Broca was an extremely respected scientist. However he, like other scientists of his time, believed that skull size was directly proportional to intelligence. Next, he mentions L. Manouvrier, and states that while he was a “black sheep” in his field, he believed that “women displayed their talents and their diplomas.” This showed that some scientists had the ability to disregard the social norm, although those who did were generally forgotten. He then describes Gustave Le Bon by mentioning his own findings on women’s intelligence. Le Bon had apparently stated, “The inferiority is so obvious that no one can contest it for a moment.” However, no mention is made of any of his experiments that tried to prove this inferiority to be true. This shows that many scientists were convinced that facts were facts and that they could not be proven to be untrue. These three scientists work in the same field, but could not be more different. Broca is seen to be well-respected and factual, Manouvrier is viewed as unpopular yet sympathetic, and Le Bon is seen as outspoken and rude. However, they each have something in common: they lack evidence aside from numbers to support their ideas thoroughly. This shows that comparison and contrast is used to build a foundation for Gould’s argument because it introduces the audience to a few scientists and how they each focus too much on basic facts to support something misunderstood.

Core Question 2: Why does Gould use a hyperbole to describe Gustave Le Bon? (50 Essays, 132)
Gould uses a hyperbole to prove to his audience that...

Find Another Essay On Women in Science

Jane Goodall; research paper biography; women and minorities in science

1591 words - 6 pages time (The Goodall Institute). Many of her parents' friends thought the young girl would be scared by the stuffed animal, but instead she loved it. In fact, she still has Jubilee in her home more than 60 years later (The Goodall Institute).As a child, Jane had a boundless interest in animals. Once, while visiting a farm, she hid in a henhouse for five hours waiting for a hen to lay an egg (Women in Science 81). Even in her youth, Jane exhibited

Marie Curie: One of the Most Influential Women in Science

1026 words - 4 pages one gram of Radium to recognize her great service to Science. Curie is known as one of the most important women in the science. Her work influenced the development of Science as well as it helped in medical research and treatment using Radium. In 1920 Marie learned that the exposure to radiation had caused her a double cataract and after four operations she was able to see again. When sick Marie did not attend her lab but rather worked on her

Notorios Women in the Science World: Marie Sklodowska Curie

1377 words - 6 pages Both a remarkably intelligent and profound female in the science world, Marie Skłodowska Curie changed the way science would be looked at in the future. Curie discovered the elements radium and polonium, as well as administering ground-breaking research in radioactivity. Both a chemist and a physicist, Curie won an extent of awards and honors in multiple fields. Curie set the stage for many years of boundless discoveries. Born to Bronisława

Men Versus Women as Defined by Science and Literature

1728 words - 7 pages Since civilization began, man has done numerous studies of the world’s natural wonders attempting to crack down the world’s seemingly complex and unsolvable mysteries. However, there is one phenomenon that no amount of science or math skills can decipher completely. The relationship between men and women has been a topic of interest for generations. Spectrums consisting from interpersonal relations to the differences of brain functions and

How Marie Curie's Discovery of Radium Transformed Science, Medicine and the Roles of Women throughout History

1925 words - 8 pages Marie Curie is the most influential person in history. Her discovery of radium and its uses in science and technology have grown rapidly throughout history, which has contributed to everything from health science to national security. Medical care and airport security would not be as accurate or efficient without X-ray machines and radiotherapy. Marie Curie’s discovery of radium transformed science, medicine, and the roles of women throughout

Ap European History DBQ: Women in the scientific revolution

1104 words - 4 pages learning science. Although this was a great change for women, there were changing attitudes and views toward them when they had participated in science. Dorothea Erxleben, a German M.D. had appreciated that she learned science, but other people, such as men felt that they she and along with other women are taking away man's superiority role in society. There were defiantly both pros and cons towards women's participation in science. (Document 9

Women and Engineering

1606 words - 6 pages Within living memory, young women who have wanted to study engineering faced such dissent that in 1955, Penn State’s dean of engineering declared, “Women are NOT for engineering,” asserting that all but a few “unusual women” lacked the “basic capabilities” necessary to succeed in this profession (Bix par. 2). Although the number of women in social sciences and humanities has grown steadily, women remain underrepresented in science and

The Outlook for Girls In Engineering and Mathematics

2201 words - 9 pages areas of science, technology, engineering, and mathematics employers are not getting enough women (Pozniak). High school girls only represent 17 percent of computer science Advance Placement (AP) test takers (O'Shea). The most significant group of minorities who are behind in earning computer technology degrees and working in science and mathematical professions are women. “Historically, women’s low representation in science and engineering was

Ap european history dbq- women

1016 words - 4 pages , it was the perfect field for them to begin their pursuit of equality. As a result, a growing number of women actively participated in scientific research in chemistry, astronomy, biology, botany, medicine, and entomology.In documents two and five the women's interests in science, as well as their need for some sort of education were expressed. Document five simply explains that women, as well as men, can hold an interest, as well as succeed in

Women's Role in Science and Technology

2454 words - 10 pages Women's Role in Science and Technology Women have played an important role in the development of science and technology, but there is an insufficient number of females in those career fields. Technological change has affected the roles of women and gender role ideas. Women without doubt came a long way improving the numbers and increasing the percentages in the workforce of Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics (STEM

Gender Differences in Mathematics and Science Learning

616 words - 3 pages Gender problems adjoining mathematics and science learning have been investigated for decades. Nevertheless, the current climate calls for even more research endeavors to contest statements and beliefs that “innate differences between men and women might be one reason fewer women succeed in science and math careers”. This particular belief may be challenged from the success of all-girl private school environments where 90% of the student

Similar Essays

Women In Science Careers Essay

2291 words - 9 pages According to a six-year study reviewed by the University of Washington Human Rights Committee, conducted by Suzanne Brainard and Linda Carlin on undergraduate women in science, “20% of freshmen reported no barriers; only 3% of seniors could say the same.”(Bickenstaff 380) This study illustrates a common theme for women studying a science. There is no one defining reason for why women feel there are barriers but several theories suggest that

Dbq On Women In Science Essay

600 words - 3 pages In the 17th and 18th centuries women in science emerged that regarded themselves correct in doing so. Also there were those who announced their opinions to the world that women should not practice science and some who believed the women can and should practice science. Many women scientist upheld and defended their positions as learned, scientific individuals. Marie Meurdrac, a French scientist, in a foreword to a publication stated clearly

Women In Science, Math, And Engineering

3297 words - 13 pages Women in Science, Math, and Engineering The statistics can be somewhat startling, while women receive 56% of BA degrees in the United States, they receive only 37% of the Science, Mathematics, and Engineering (SME) bachelor degrees (Chang, 1). As scary as the statistics on women are, they only point to an even bigger problem among all SME majors. According to one study, there is a 40% decline in the number of undergraduate science

The Male Ego And The Perception Of Women In Science

1035 words - 4 pages The Male Ego and the Perception of Women in Science In the beginning, there were as many women in science as there were men. Most myths and religions credit women for the invention of agriculture, law, civilization, math, time measurement, and medicine (Newintro). Think about how many different goddesses there have been in mythology. Since then, politics, power, pride, and prejudice have motivated many men and some women to discourage women