Workfare: A Good Way To Govern The Poor?

2610 words - 10 pages - by remiexchange ✓ Expert Reviewed

Introduction
This essay will examine the technique of workfare as a way of governing the poor. Workfare is a widely contested area which evokes many conflicting opinions at both the political and the public level. The following quote comes from Dan Hodges, a British commentator writing for The Daily Telegraph, and gives an interesting insight in one of the discussions workfare poses. Hodges writes about the way several proponents of workfare (including David Cameron, British PM), who are quite successful themselves with their careers, condemn unemployed citizens to do anything but pleasant jobs without getting a reasonable compensation:

‘What rule says workfare must be the same old hardy staples: stack a shelf, clean a floor? If we want to really open people's eyes to the opportunities of work, why rely on Tesco and Sainsbury? We should be co-opting the Apples and the Microsofts, the BAs and the Virgins, the Jaguars and the BMWs. And instead of boycotting firms that provide the placements, we should be making business participation mandatory. David Cameron says the opponents of workfare are "snobs". Fine. Then it's time we saw someone on a workfare placement getting into the back of his Land Rover and carrying a couple of those red boxes for him. Similarly, if Sir Stuart Rose is really concerned about the "lack of backbone" from firms pulling out of the scheme, he can set an example by appointing another personal assistant for a couple of months’ (Hodges, 2012).

This essay will cover an analysis of arguments from both proponents and opponents of workfare. In addition, there will be looked at the emphasis supporters of workfare place on the notion of ‘work ethic’. First, the concept of ‘workfare’ will be unpacked. Second, the arguments of both proponents and opponents of workfare will be examined in a critical way. This includes a provision of my own opinion about the issue. Last, the foregoing will be briefly summarised in the conclusion.

Concept
What does the word ‘workfare’ exactly mean? And how does workfare differs from welfare? Jamie Peck, in his book Workfare States, argues that the essence of workfare is ‘the imposition of a range of compulsory programs and mandatory requirements for welfare recipients with a view to enforcing work while residualising welfare’ (Peck, 2001; 10). In other words, workfare focusses on maximising work participation while minimising one’s dependency on welfare. Peck shows that the meaning of workfare is quite controversial, and that many people perceive it in a different way. However, he shows that all of these meanings share the element that instead of providing an income security program based on financial need, the state provides a program which is conditional on the performance of employment activity in exchange for benefits (ibid.; 10). Peck also elaborates on the differences between workfare and welfare. According to him, welfare stands for needs-based entitlement, universality and passive income...

Find Another Essay On Workfare: a good way to govern the poor?

The Best Way to Feed a Baby

1285 words - 5 pages For years there have been arguments about which is the best way to feed a baby. Many women going through their pregnancy struggling with what decision is right for them because ultimately it is a behavior that is natural to our species and those like us. There are two options to choose from when deciding how to feed an infant after birth. The first is breastfeeding either by bottle or breast and the second is formula feeding a baby. This paper...

Drinking the Way to a New Age

2542 words - 10 pages caught and a mass of speakeasies was closed down, yet others prevailed until the end of Prohibition. No doubt, this behavior seen over eighty years ago may be linked to the behavior seen now among teenagers and young adults. After Prohibition was repealed, it was left up to the states to decide how to govern alcohol consumption. Most states made 21 the legal drinking age, although a handful required drinkers to be only 18. No national drinking age...

Was the British Empire a good thing that enlarged the world creating possibilities for everyone or was it just a way for some to gain power and wealth?

772 words - 3 pages British preferred to rule its empire for reasons such as finances, fear of conflict, and governmental responsibilities and burdens. There were times when formal rule was required, and Britain's self image of power gave it the will to use force if necessary. Imperialism is the way in which a group gains formal or informal influence over another group's politics, society, and economy.Firstly, there isn't an explanation why Britain gained so much...

Boot Camps: A Good Way to Deter Youth Offenders in Queensland?

1688 words - 7 pages examine whether they are a useful avenue to follow. The use of boot camps has been controversial in many countries around the world, such as the United States, Canada and the United Kingdom and this paper will examine whether these controversial camps would be a good way to deter youth offenders within Queensland. With the introduction of the Youth Justice (Boot Camp Orders) 2012 Amendment bill it was hoped that the youth would have a real chance...

Are the Poor to Blame for Being Poor

1518 words - 6 pages Introduction Poverty is determined by the amount of income that is produced by a family prior to taxes; if this amount is below the threshold determined by the government then they are considered poor (Schriver, 2011). Poverty refers to individuals who are at the bottom of the income distribution and they are unable to provide themselves with the basic necessities to maintain a healthy life. Schriver (2011) stated that poverty is experience...

Are the Poor to Blame for Being Poor

1645 words - 7 pages program that put limitations on benefits, this generation cycle was broken. Now cash assistance is no longer an entitlement to the poor but a short- term program that varies from state to state (Zastrow & Kirst-Ashman, 2013). In 1996 the United States abolished the Aid to Families with Dependent Children (AFDC) and replaced it with Temporary Aid Needy Families (TANF). This decision changed what was considered welfare to “workfare”. The federal program...

To Learn the Way

1502 words - 6 pages Ilemona had just got back from the market and was about to start preparing supper. The sun was going down and Baba would be back home soon. He didn’t like it when he had to wait for his evening meal. She had to hurry. The little children in their family compound were playing with an old car tyre, taking turns to move it around with a stick while the older children where playing Whots. They had started to argue that Ocheja had cheated in the card...

Self-service travelling is a good way of travel other than joining the tour

1037 words - 4 pages In the 20th century, self-service travelling is famous around the international cities. Self-served tour can definitely be a good way of travel other than the package tour. When it comes to the package tour, most of its itineraries are general with a short period of time. According to a survey conducted by Independent Traveler’s World (cited in Travelmole 2002), the number of interviewees go travel through agents decline from 56% to 28% which...

Leadership Is a Way to Change the Minds of Others

915 words - 4 pages Leadership has been described as "a process of social influence in which one person can enlist the aid and support of others in the accomplishment of a common task", however there are alternative definitions of leadership. Leadership is a major way in which people change the minds of others and move organizations forward to accomplish identified goals. According to Fry et al (2004) stated that, “leaders must exhibit high levels of courage with a...

CRM in insurance: A novel way to beat the odds

2109 words - 8 pages CRM in insurance: A novel way to beat the oddsIn today's dynamic world, the importance of good customer service is becoming more and more apparent. With the blurring up of differences between banking, broking and insurance; coupled with industry consolidations; demutualization; shrinking margins; profitability pressures; and new distribution channels; the insurance companies are being forced to rethink their business models for...

Bi-Bi: A Better Way to Educate the Deaf

2681 words - 11 pages these misconceptions have been disproved. We have learned that there is a better way of educating our deaf students: Bicultural-Bilingual (bi-bi) educational methods. Some of the consequences of the Milan Conference include the banning of the use of signed languages in the classroom and making it so deaf could not educate other deaf. Which eliminated the blossoming bilingual education programs that were starting to emerge. Now that the use of...

Similar Essays

Is giving money to the poor really the best way to help them?

946 words - 4 pages financial aid to these less fortunate individuals. However, the root of this problem can only be destroyed upon digging deeper and recognizing the problems in the lives of underprivileged. It is commonly said, "Help the poor by giving them money". But, the idea that giving poor people money is really the best way to help them, should be reconsidered. We should not provide poorer...

A way to the past Essay

945 words - 4 pages Anne was a simple child who was always looking for a way out of everything. If she was told to do the dishes, she would find every possible thing to do besides the dishes. She was a perfect angel before her mother Clairabeth ‘had an accident’ last year in 2012. Now she is perfect at resisting. That’s where I come in. I have come to tell our fantastic adventure. She was in the kitchen and her dad was making toast. “Anne darling, will you please...

Is The Idea Of A Contract A Good Way Of Explaining Why We Ought To Do Things?

1728 words - 7 pages Theory of Politics - Week 1 Is the idea of a contract a good way of explaining why we ought to do things even though we do not want to? Is it a good way of explaining anything else? A working definition of a contract, for students such as myself who are largely unfamiliar with the definition of the term, is a promise that the law will enforce. The law provides remedies if a...

Does Benjamin Franklin’s preface to Poor Richard Improved, "The Way to Wealth" apply to the Modern Era?

1095 words - 4 pages Richard Improved, "The Way to Wealth", Franklin proffers many adages to help the reader attain and maintain personal satisfaction and wealth. Many of these sayings are true and applicable even today. Franklin clearly believes that both frugality and industry was imperative and that wealth was a bi-product of those indeavors. Franklin as Poor Richard in his Almanac of 1733 tells us "However, let us hearken to good advice, and...