Workplace Law Case Study Analysis

1745 words - 7 pages

QuestionMr and Mrs Donegan own a pharmacy. The pharmacy was busy so they decided to employ 19-year-old university student Elizabeth Matthews. Elizabeth commenced work at the pharmacy in December 2003.Mrs Donegan: "We'll pay you $12 an hour. There won't be any set hours but we'll probably need you after university every day and on Saturdays. Ok?"Elizabeth: "Ok."Mrs Donegan: "We'll give you your earnings in cash on Thursday nights. You know, it's up to you if you want to speak to the tax office about deducting tax from what we give you. You probably like to go down south during university holidays - that will still be all right but, of course, you won't be paid for those periods."Elizabeth signed a contract detailing the agreement reached with the Donegans. Elizabeth worked very hard at the pharmacy. Her duties involved tidying up the shelves in the shop and in the storeroom, as well as serving customers. Mr Donegan insisted that all pharmaceutical products be shelved in reverse alphabetical order on the floor of the storeroom and Elizabeth spent many challenging hours ensuring that this system was adhered to. Mr Donegan also gave her a half-day training in shop etiquette.It is now May 2005. Sadly, Elizabeth has just taken four weeks off work due to a nasty outbreak of boils on her face but the Donegans have refused to pay her sick leave. Is Elizabeth entitled to sick leave?What are the legal issues?1. Firstly it is important to establish whether or not a relationship of employer/employee exists between Elizabeth and the Donegans (as distinguished from one of hirer/independent contractor)2. Is there an employment contract?3. What are the agreed terms of this contract?4. What type of contract of employment does Elizabeth have? Is she a casual or part-time employee?5. If she has a contract, does this type of contract entitle her to sick leave pay from the Donegans?What are the legal principles and the case precedents and/or statutory provisions applicable to these particular legal issues?Elizabeth's agreement with the Donegans encompasses indicia from both the Control test and the Multi-factor test; which are the current tests used in Australia for determining whether or not a contract of employment exists.The control test is the classic test for determining whether or not a contract of employment exists. It is made up of two elements- the nature of control and the degree of control. The case of Stevens v Brodribb Sawmilling Company Pty Ltd (1986) 140 CLR 16 provides authority for this proposition of law.Whilst the multi-factor test is headed by this issue of control, it is also made up of other important indicia. These include:* Mode of remuneration* Provision and maintenance of equipment by worker* Obligation to work* Provision for leave* Unable to delegate work* Deduction of income tax* The employer's right to have a particular person do the work* The right to suspend or dismiss the person engaged* The right to the exclusive services of the person...

Find Another Essay On Workplace Law - Case study analysis

Analysis of The Types of Law in a Case Study

2204 words - 9 pages notice near the entrance at Big Deal ltd will be void and thus will have not legal affect. The same applies to Slump Ltd and they will have the ability to claim compensation plus damages.From the analysis of both scenarios in the question, it can be ascertained that there are remedies for both injured parties against Big Deal Ltd.For Slump Ltd, the exclusion clause is not relevant to their case as it does not satisfy the conditions needed to be

Case Study Analysis

1156 words - 5 pages Case Study Analysis: The patient,MMMM, needs a blood transfusion and possibly surgery to save her life as well as the life of her unborn child related to an injury she sustained from a motor vehicle accident. The patient does not want to receive blood products or surgery. The patient's reluctance is related to her faith, which is based upon biblical scripture pertaining to blood. The primary ethical issue in this case is the patient's right to

Case Study Analysis

2396 words - 10 pages treat them with disrespect or without moral values. Works Cited JAU-SHIN HONl, MING-YUEH TARNG, & Po-Young, C. (2000). A case study exploring acer's global logistics and innovation. Management International, 5, 21-30. Retrieved from http://search.proquest.com/docview/204426199?accountid=32521 About the Acer group. (1998). Organizational Dynamics, 27(1), 66. Retrieved from http://search.proquest.com/docview/210599601?accountid=32521 Reckford, J

Case Study Analysis

998 words - 4 pages Case Study AnalysisIntroductionThis is a case study analysis of Carl Robins, a new campus recruiter for ABC, Inc. Carl has enlisted and hired 15 new employees who are to be trained and work for Monica Carrolls, who is the Operations Supervisor. Carl has failed however to make the necessary arrangements for the new trainee orientation that is scheduled to take place on June 15. He also has neglected to follow-up with each of the new trainees

Xerox Case Study Analysis

1023 words - 4 pages Xerox Case Study Analysis Xerox's "Book In Time" is a revolutionary product, presenting some new opportunities for the company. It is simply a matter of costs. The Book-in-Time equipment allows for a publishing company to produce a 300-page book for $6.90, something which could have been previously reached only for lots larger than 1,000 copies. A significant decrease in publishing costs, given the fact that these cover up to 20

Analysis of the Case Law

3355 words - 13 pages Analysis of the Case Law "There is no prescribed constitutional relationship between the courts and the executive, but the judges assert their inherent power, derived from the rule of law, to review executive actions" The question starts off by giving us an element of the separation of powers when it says that there is no prescribed

UK Employment Law Case study of fighting in the workplace, citing the cases of Meyer Dunmore Ltd v Rogers (1978) and Post Office v Fennell (1981) Johnson v Marney Superstores PLC

2202 words - 9 pages application for unfair dismissal must be issued within 3 months of the date of termination of the employment unless a case can be made to the tribunal stating that it was not reasonably practical to do this within this time.There are certain categories of employees who are excluded from bringing an unfair dismissal case such as the police and the armed forces, people who have reached the normal retiring age (or 65 if there is no normal retiring age) and

Australian Law and Business - case study

2464 words - 10 pages can be established in which Fred has failed to complete what has been agreed to in the contract. Boris has the right to sue against Fred for his damages to compensate Boris for loss caused by Fred’s breach of contract. In this case, the possible damages incurred to Boris is the $5,000 deposit paid at the first sitting.RecommendationIn view of the above analysis on the legal aspect of Breach of collateral contract, Misrepresentation

Tough Guy Case Study Analysis

1816 words - 8 pages Analysis: Tough Guy Case Study The Tough Guy Case Study examines the employees of investment bank Hudson Smith Gordon (“Hudson”) and their reactions to the behavior of one of its vice presidents, Chip Mazey (Yemen & Clawson, 2007). This analysis will discuss the issues of unresolved conflict among Hudson employees and possible remedies to consider. Recommendations will be provided which should be implemented by Hudson management to minimize

Social Media Case Study Analysis

935 words - 4 pages Social Media Case Study Analysis Effective communication in an organization is one of the components of its success. Managers are charged with navigating communication obstacles while making every effort to harness its benefits. This onus placed on managers is compounded by organizational advancements and the application of new technologies. One relatively new organizational technology being applied is the use of social media. Social media

Analysis of Tumi’s Case Study

1099 words - 4 pages . We analysis Tumi’s case study through the two elected perspectives and discuss on what evidence in the case study will support that specific perspective. We will also discuss which of the two perspectives has more evidence and which is based on fact rather than belief. The biological perspective was founded by James Old, in 1958. The biological perspective studies the chemical and the biological process of the central nervous system. The

Similar Essays

Workplace Case Study

1739 words - 7 pages industry to find some marketing guru's to help them with their tired product lines. The second alternative for this case study has to deal with the relocation of the company from Philadelphia to Florida where the new CEO had his home. Even if the company was going to be forced to lay off 11,000 people, there should have been more discussion and analysis around their decision to move to Florida. The last alternative is the research into all the

Commercial Law Case Study

1783 words - 7 pages ). According to the Case Donoghue v Allied Newpaper Ltd (1938) 1 CH 106 applies that a picture, a play, or a book, and the owner of the idea has no rights in the product (Turner 2003, p848). Even the book is based on Gilbert's life story, but author of the book is jack and has the copyright of the book.A basic principle of copyright law is that copyright does not protect ideas as such but only the particular form of expression in which they are embodied

Law Case Study

1459 words - 6 pages Law Case Study X owns a holiday cottage in a remote mountain area. In May he agreed to let it to Y from 1-15 August. Y paid a deposit of £ 200. On the afternoon of 31 July, after Y and his family had set off from their

Contract Law Case Study

3017 words - 12 pages Contract Law Case Study Both the parties in the question have come to a problematic situation which is complicated to resolve. Friend's of the Forest (Friends), represented by Christabel, is involved in a commercial trade with Paper Supplies Pty Ltd (Paper) which is represented by Dee. A contract needs four essential elements to exist. In the