World War Ii D Day Essay

1174 words - 5 pages

D-Day

Throughout the course of World War II, there were several American raids, or invasions, of European soil. Young American soldiers risked their own lives in order to save those of thousands of others. The most famous of these invasions happened on the beaches of Normandy, Where US and British forces ran into a strong German resistance . This battle has been studied and glorified by many American historians throughout the years. Every historian has his or her own take on this event, but almost all American historians will express it as an important United States victory.

In his article “Questionable Objective: The Brittany Ports, 1944”, A. Harding Ganz focuses on the “logistical planning” and “strategic considerations” of high ranking officials during the invasion . He continues talk of planning and proper procedures, and eventually encounters the actual battle itself. He describes the D-Day invasion in terms of the raw number of soldiers, but soon changes his positive outlook on the invasion. He says:

On 6 June 1944 the allied forces invaded Festung Europa in Operation Overload.
The Normandy beachhead was successfully established, but stubborn German
resistance resulted in the drawn-out “Battle of the Build-Up” as men and material
were brought ashore. With stalemated Normandy fighting…”

It is clear that Ganz had a pro-invasion stance, but was willing to admit that fighting in Normandy had resulted in at least a temporary stalemate. “The Battle of Normandy: The Lingering Controversy”, as written by Stephen T. Powers, shines a whole new light on the invasion. He too sees D-Day as an important allied victory, but calls it “a stunning success, even though disaster was narrowly averted by the American V Corps on Omaha Beach.” Powers continues to explain the tactics and planning of the invasion, and subsequent battles, just as Ganz does. He does go a little more in depth than Ganz while describing policies; he also portrays those men who made the policies. Powers describes General Bernard L. Montgomery, overall ground commander for the battle of Normandy, as a “vain, self-centered, troublesome general”.

Ganz and Powers clearly glorify the D-Day battles, and attribute the allied victory to these incidents; Joseph Forbes has an entirely different view of this particular invasion. He suggests that there were several other battles that are worthy of attention and praise. When discussing the planning of a possible invasion of Japan, He is quoted as saying:

“But James has presented no evidence that the adjustments in the Olympia
invasion planning would preclude an invasion of Japan in late fall. General
(Dwight D.) Eisenhower, commander of the Normandy invasion, has pointed
out that several serious problems were encountered in the planning of
Overload, and the plans were altered and adjusted several times. Yet all the
Problems and adjustments did not stop D-Day from taking place.”

This shows that...

Find Another Essay On World War II - D-Day

World War II Essay

1084 words - 4 pages World War II for the United States started with the tragic event that happened on the island of Oahu; Hawaii. Japan had bombed Pearl Harbor and that had got America enraged so America reacted by declaring war on Japan, this would be the start of World War II for America. Soon after America had entered World War II, they joined the Allies team, fighting against the Germans, Italy and Japanese. Fighting on the Allies side included Britain, Soviet

World War II Essay

2488 words - 10 pages , Franklin D. Roosevelt, Joseph Stalin, and Charles de Gaulle. Winston Churchill was prime minister of Britain during most of World War II. Franklin D. Roosevelt was one of the greatest presidents of United States History. Joseph Stalin was titled General Secretary of the Communist Party. He led the Russian’s through very overwhelming battles with Germany and set up the Eastern Bloc of Soviet led communist states after the war was won. Charles de

World War II

2850 words - 11 pages ). Inferno The World At War, 1939 - 1945. New York: Alfred A Knopf, a division of Random House, Inc.Miller, D. (2001). The Story of World War II. New York, New York: Simon & Schuster, Inc.Production, D. D. (Director). (2012). Victory At Sea [Motion Picture].

World War II

517 words - 2 pages The involvement of the United States in World War I was inevitable. If the U.S. had not entered the war, the result may have swung the other way. However, with their involvement in the war, the Allies were able to seal their final victory through military aid from the United States in the form of troops, rations, supplies, and war vehicles. The United States' involvement in World War II was also inevitable, mainly because of the attacks made on

World War II Narrative

937 words - 4 pages took place primarily in the 13 Colonies, which were controlled by the British, and the Americans fought for their independence. The Americans eventually won their independence from the British. This is an example of a cause and effect of a war. There were multiple causes of World War II, which mainly included Hitler wanting to conquer all of Europe and make it his own, and Germany, Italy, and Japan conquering their neighbors (Ellis and Esler, 925

World War II - 1271 words

1271 words - 5 pages an establishment on Western Allied forces ,during WWII,the largest amphibious invasion to ever take place. This is where we get the term D-Day.The conquests of World War II began at the invasion of Poland.Adolf Hitler turned to the totalitarian dictator of the Soviet Union, Joseph Stalin, and made an alliance with him. The agreement was called the Nazi-Soviet Pact of August of 1939. In this alliance, the both agreed on the invading of Eastern

World War II - 1271 words

1271 words - 5 pages an establishment on Western Allied forces ,during WWII,the largest amphibious invasion to ever take place. This is where we get the term D-Day.The conquests of World War II began at the invasion of Poland.Adolf Hitler turned to the totalitarian dictator of the Soviet Union, Joseph Stalin, and made an alliance with him. The agreement was called the Nazi-Soviet Pact of August of 1939. In this alliance, the both agreed on the invading of Eastern

World War II - 1241 words

1241 words - 5 pages On the early morning of December 7th 1941, hundreds of Japanese bombers surprise attacked Pearl Harbor, a U.S. naval base in Hawaii. Around 2,000 U.S. soldiers were killed that day in the attack. What was the U.S. supposed to do other than retaliate? The surprise attack finally brought a reluctant U.S. into the war. After 4 years of excruciating war, it had to end.The man who saw the U.S. through most of the war was President Franklin D

World War II Poetry

1347 words - 6 pages was not any personification, alliteration , or repetition in the poem. (Smith) In America boys were forced to join the military when they were 18 years old and out of high school. They had no other choice. Their only choice was which branch of the military they wanted to pursue. There was the army, navy, air force, etc. When World War II began the schools started to verbally prepare the boys. On graduation day they let all the boys know that

World War II Speech

1133 words - 5 pages I. World War II was the most devastating war in world history. The war resulted in horrific property damage as well as about 17 million military deaths and even more civilian deaths….(click) The devastation of the war was mainly due to the advanced military weapons used, from the infantry on the front line to the ships in the sea and the planes in the sky, these weapons destroyed lives and property in nearly every part of the world. The

World War II - 2335 words

2335 words - 9 pages the history of mankind. It also marked a significant turning point in the second World War, one that would aid in the eventual defeat and downfall of Hilter's armies. The release of Steven Spielberg's Saving Private Ryan will rekindle a lot of interest in the second World War, and in particular the real events which took place on June 6, 1944 - also known as D-Day. D-Day WEB has been established as a companion site to

Similar Essays

Deception, Advantage, And D Day: World War Ii

2592 words - 10 pages According to Sun Tzu’s book, The Art of War, he states, “All war is based on deception” (“D-Day as a Parable”). The Allied Invasion of Normandy, code named Operation Overlord, on June 6, 1944, was considered the most decisive and deceptive battle in Western Europe between the Allied and the Axis powers. The Allies were led by Britain, France, and the United States in the Western front and the Soviet Union in the Eastern front. The Axis powers

World War Ii Essay 1252 Words

1252 words - 6 pages Adolf Hitler. This name has gone down in history as the cause of the worst war ever, World War II. Because of this man, 85 million men, women, and children were brutally killed. But World War II’s pre and post stages were almost just as bad with World War I before, and the Cold War after. Because of these three events happening in the order they did, World War II turned out to be one of the scariest times on Earth. The bloodiest War in

World War Ii Essay 1859 Words

1859 words - 7 pages United States declared war. The war was made up of a series of major events such as the Battle of El Alamein, the Battle of Leyte Gulf, the Battle of Stalingrad, and D-Day which all lead to the victory of the Allied powers. Multiple events lead to the declaration of World War II, such as Germany’s invasion of Poland and the attack on Pearl Harbor. On September 1, 1939, attacked Poland after promising not to invade any other countries. Germany took

World War Ii Essay 1618 Words

1618 words - 7 pages the Japanese army and it represented a turning point where the allies had an advantage Book Supplement Addition: In A Child’s War; World War II Through the Eyes of Children, the Americans bomb Hiroshima which finally makes Japan surrender (pg 156). Source: Navajo Code Talkers: World War II Fact Sheet O Order of the Day Who: Dwight D. Eisenhower Where: Fort Bragg's Advanced Airborne School When: June 6th, 1944 What: General Eisenhower gave troops