This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Writers And Intellectuals In Exile Essay

2807 words - 12 pages

Ankita Rathee
Professor Priya Kumar
SC- 6, MA English Sem IV
Enrolment no.: SV- 88/09
April 21, 2014
Writers and Intellectuals in Exile
“It may be that writers in my position, exiles… are haunted by some sense of loss, some urge to reclaim, to look back, even at the risk of being mutated into pillars of salt”1 said Salman Rushdie. The loss and love of home is not what constitutes an exilic existence; what actually and in true sense constitutes it is the chasm between carrying forth and leaving behind and straddling the two different cultures from two different positions. In my paper, I propose to look at the two sides of an exilic existence- the negative that which has the horrors and trauma with reference to Adorno and Said; and the positive, that which provides the intellectuals and writers a critical and reflective insight, and here I would refer to JanMohamed and Salman Rushdie with special reference to Said’s “contrapuntal” effect. I would then proceed to the ‘enabling’ aspect of exile which involves the agential process of hybridity where I will bring in Homi K. Bhabha’s take on it and his concept of “third space”.
“Exile originated in the age old practice of banishment. Once banished, the exile lives an anomalous and miserable life, with the stigma of an outsider”2 said Edward Said. Adorno in the 13th terse “Protection, Help and Counsel” of Minima Moralia asserts that, “every intellectual in emigration is without exception, damaged and does well to acknowledge it to himself… He lives in an environment that must remain incomprehensible to him… Relation between outcasts are even more poisoned than between long standing residents.”3 Adorno’s reflection epitomizes the common understanding of exilic experience as one of trauma, estrangement and paranoia. Numerous autobiographical accounts confirm this devastating assessment and testify to the exiles frequent sense of pain and loss.
Edward Said brings out this quandary as well in “Reflections on Exile” where he expresses that,
Exile is a jealous state… It is in the drawing of lines around you and your compatriots that the least attractive aspects of exile emerge; an exaggerated sense of group solidarity, even those who are in the same predicament as you… perhaps this the most extraordinary of exile’s fate; to have been exiled by the exiles (Said, 178).
Exile in itself is a traumatic experience and becomes more aggravated owing to the formation of strong opinionated groups based on the political affiliations or the social construct. Both Adorno and Said enunciate this predicament of the exiles where isolation becomes so worse that exiled groups start suspecting their own members. The moment the formation of politically directed groups begin to take shape, the suspicion and hostility towards “those branded as the members of others” (Adorno, 33) too simultaneously commences. Adorno says, “The moment when you hope for the slightest sigh of the same solidarity from them, or even mere sympathy...

Find Another Essay On Writers and Intellectuals in Exile

Difference Between Romanticism And Transendinlalism In American And British Writers

2672 words - 11 pages the British and American writers that have chosen either the path of romanticism or transendinlalism. The characteristics of Romanticism are different to those of Transendinlalism. Romanticism results in part from the libertarian and egalitarian ideals of the French Revolution, the romantic movements had in common only a revolt against the prescribed rules of classicism. The basic aims of romanticism were various: a return

Communicating in relationships according to linguists, psychologists, and writers

940 words - 4 pages Communicating in a relationship can be challenging and must be approached in a particular way. Many problems can be created without the proper kind of communication, including misunderstandings, which can lead to fights or arguments. By following some simple guidelines set by linguists, psychologists, and writers, such as Susan Page, Deborah Tannen, and John Gray, couples can learn to understand each other, therefore having healthy relationships

F. Scott Fitzgeral and His Impact in American Literature and Other Writers

958 words - 4 pages F. Scott Fitzgerald once said, “You don’t write because you want to say something, you write because you have something to say” (qtd. in Goodreads). In Fitzgerald's life he overcame many obstacles such as alcoholism and his wife going to an insane asylum, but tragedy often creates the most spectacular writers. His skill is seen in almost every piece he produced,which in turn created a legend. F. Scott Fitzgerald revolutionized American

Three Women Writers: A Study in Virtue and Christianity of the 18th and 19th centuries

2374 words - 9 pages Three Women Writers: A Study in Virtue and Christianity of the 18th and 19th centuries The popularity of Toni Morrison's Beloved has recently awakened a mainstream interest in African-American literature. Writers, such as Maya Angelou and Langston Hughes, have also facilitated the infiltration of African American voices into popular culture. This website is devoted to three women who, like Morrison and Angelou, have aided in the formation and

Powerless against the world. This is an analytical essay about exile and idenity in the book I Said With Magellan by Stuart Dybek

1473 words - 6 pages exile them not only from society, but also from their true identity.Well known author Stuart Dybek gives his accounts of exile and a collection of short stories he has titled I Sailed with Magellan. Although these stories are all fictional, some believe them to be somewhat autobiographical. These stories all take place in Chicago where Dybek grew up, and in the same type of town where he was raised. Each one of these stories has its own type of

The Power of Writing in Louder than a Bomb, Freedom Writers and Finding Forrester

853 words - 4 pages The power of writing is not only limited to telling a story on a piece of paper, but can help many grow wiser as individuals and bring many closer as a community. Finding Forrester, Louder Than A Bomb and Freedom Writers depicted the growth of maturity in the characters personalities alongside with improving their writing and reading skills. In these films, writing was used as a life-changing tool for the characters to expand their personal

Existentialism in the early 19th Century. Speaks of writers and philosophers

1614 words - 6 pages that situation is superior to that of a detached, objective observer. This emphasis on the perspective of the individual agent has also made existentialists suspicious of systematic reasoning. Kierkegaard, Nietzsche, and other existentialist writers have been deliberately unsystematic in the exposition of their philosophies, preferring to express themselves in aphorisms, dialogues, parables, and other literary forms. Despite their antirationalist

Compare the ways the writers present the relationships between parents and children in Romeo and Juliet, Her Father and My father thought it Blood

1659 words - 7 pages In this essay, I am going to compare the ways the writers present the relationship between parents and children in Romeo and Juliet, Her Father and My father thought it Bloody Queer. All parents love, care and protect their children in different ways. At the beginning of Act 1 scene 2 in “Romeo and Juliet”, Lord Capulet seems like a caring and loving character as he is reluctant to allow Juliet to get married with whomever she loves. At this

Explore the Ways the Writers Present the Outcast in Hamlet, Wuthering Heights and One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest in View of this Statement

1941 words - 8 pages writers intensify their outcast’s position through their isolation. Brontё uses the motif of windows in Wuthering Heights, to perform as a symbolic barrier which separates Heathcliff from his desires. For example when Heathcliff and Catherine venture to go spy on the Linton’s, the drawing room window provides a view into a different world, that eventually welcomes Catherine but rejects Heathcliff. When thrown out of Thrushcross Grange he is left to

An AP prompt essay discussing how writers must prepare to be unsatisfied and must not be concerned about flattery because success in writing comes only with maturity

728 words - 3 pages accomplished writer without having years of wisdom behind you. Throughout the passage, she utilizes various persuasive techniques such as refutation and analogies in order to depict novice work as tasteless. In Lewes response to Peirce, she incorporates many rhetorical strategies in order to convey that writers must prepare to be unsatisfied and must not be concerned about flattery because success in writing comes only with maturity.In the beginning

"An Age of Melancholy Musings" A Comprative/Contrast essay focusing on the American writers of the Neo-Classic period and the Romantic period in literature

608 words - 2 pages , having its origin in wonder and mystery.In direct contrast to the ideals of the classicists, Romanticism, stresses the freedom for the individual. It rejects restricting social conventions and unjust political rule. In literature, the Romantic hero, such as Mark Twain's "Huckleberry Finn" or "Jim" the black slave, is often a rebel or outcast of society. During the Romantic movement, most writers were discontented with their world. The world seemed

Similar Essays

Exile And Pain In Three Elegiac Poems

909 words - 4 pages contains the theme of exile.     The Wife of Lament is another perfect example of literature with exile, and was written by an unknown author. The most striking example of exile in this poem can be seen in the passage when she says, "A song I sing of sorrow unceasing, the tale of my trouble, the weight of my woe, woe of the present, and woe of the past, woe never-ending of exile, and grief, but never since girlhood

Theme Of Sacrifice In Julia Alvarez's In Liberty And Exile

652 words - 3 pages Sacrificing is the act of giving up, destroying, permitting injury to, or forgoing something valued for the sake of something having a more pressing claim. In Liberty and Exile by Julia Alvarez a lot of people have to take certain responsibilities which can involve sacrificing. Liberty is freedom from external or foreign rule. or independence. The author, Julia Alvarez, has been in simular situations to those in Liberty and Exile. " I

Gender Biases And Sexism In Writers

1310 words - 5 pages hundreds of years. Ideas that women belong in the kitchen and men should be under the hood of a car are prevalent in every society. If people believe in such drastic stereotypes, would it make sense to say that someone’s sex does not play a role in how they write? Poet Lisa Robertson is a good example of the influence gender has in poetry. Writers often have a beautiful way of saying the things that they are most passionate about and Robertson is a

Class, Exile And Trauma In Rebecca West’s "The Return Of The Soldier"

3253 words - 13 pages mention by focusing and bringing to attention the elements of class, exile from being deployed and the trauma that war causes on the soldier. The approach West uses to capture her readers is through the voice of her narrator Jenny, in which her voice gives the novel an authentic feel of the torment that the women went through while waiting for their men and loved ones to return. “As the English struggled to come to terms with the wounded