Writing An Ethnography Essay

2223 words - 9 pages

“In any war story, but especially a true one, it's difficult to separate what happened from what seemed to happen.”
- Tim O’Brien, The Things They Carried

It is not only war stories that create confusion, both for their writers, and their readers, about the nature of the truth they tell. Is the truth in a “true” story what the writer experienced, or the truth of what “really” happened? If the story is about other people, is the truth what the writer sees them do, or what they think they are doing? If the writer does not know the whole truth, does the story become false?
All these questions become even more pertinent if posed about ethnographies. An ethnography is, by nature, meant to be a description of a people (the dictionary definition actually refers to “scientific description of individual cultures,” but that brings up questions about the meaning of “scientific” and “culture”). How can a people (or a culture) be described truthfully? And what is the relationship between the idealized pursuit of truth and ethical practices?
In writing an ethnography, both what the ethnographer sees (as objectively as possible) and what the people themselves say is happening must be incorporated in a reasonable manner. The people’s words must be evaluated by the ethnographer for purposeful distortion, and taken into account with that possibility in mind. Parts of the truth may be left out if they make for a story that the people being studied do not want told about themselves. Reality may be portrayed inexactly, as long as a more general truth of it is preserved—ethnographers often make use of collective characters that are combinations of several people in real life.
These general guidelines, prescribed from a 21st-century vantage point by someone who does not have very much experience reading ethnography, have not always been followed by ethnographers. Ethnography has undergone a process of drastic evolution (or, some might say, oscillation) in the century or so that it has existed as an anthropological tool. Many aspects of ethnography have changed between two extremes that I will term “traditional” ethnography and “postmodern” ethnography. Everything from the declared goal of the anthropologist to the approach to possible objectivity or subjectivity of the anthropologist’s writing, from views on the concept of culture to the ethnography’s intended audience, even to choice of topic to explore, has changed. I will explore these differences using Coming of Age in Samoa by Margaret Mead as an example of traditional ethnography, and Poetics of Military Occupation by Smadar Lavie as an example of postmodern ethnography. Veiled Sentiments by Lila Abu-Lughod will serve as something of a mix, poised between the two extremes.
I must first, however, explain my choice of “postmodern” as a label for the kind of ethnography that Smadar Lavie produced in 1990 (based on fieldwork done throughout the 70’s). The aspect of postmodernism that I embrace in...

Find Another Essay On Writing an Ethnography

The Role of Reflexivity in Ethnography

1385 words - 6 pages herself in her own ethnographic research---seeing herself not as an “unbiased, impartial” (Malinowski 18) observer, but as an essential and un-removable part of her study. The effect of reflexivity on ethnographic writing has been, however, much broader than just that. It signals “a departure from the ideology of objectivity [and] distance” which for so long pervaded ethnography (Marcus 189). For those who choose to employ it, reflexivity offers

Ethnographic Writing and Relationships with Research Subjects

1361 words - 5 pages , “the prostitute immediately put me through a Streetwalker 101 test” (Sterk 2003: 15). She found this method though tedious and painful an accurate and non-biased way of understanding the true essence of prostitution and what the women have to go through. She stresses the importance of trust in these relationships, because it would ultimately provide the specific information needed for her ethnography. Keith Bletzer calls Sterk a ‘field instrument

The Pros and Cons of Ethnographic Reflexivity

843 words - 3 pages The Advantages and Limits of Ethnographic Reflexivity Awareness of writing choices generates an appreciation of the reflexivity of ethnographic research. Reflexivity involves the recognition that an account of reality does not simply mirror reality but rather creates or constitutes as real in the first place whatever it describes. Thus ‘the notion of reflexivity recognizes that texts do not simply and transparently report an independent order

Ethnocentrism

1015 words - 4 pages anthropology to study about the past and how understand more about the culture of ethnic groups. Both of these fields emphasizes on the significantly useful for an anthropologist. According to the book ethnography is "a detailed description of a particular culture primarily based on fieldwork, which is the term all anthology use for on-location research." Ethnography study includes describing and analyzing details of cultures. In other words, these type

Anthropology

1333 words - 5 pages position to comprehend the force of anger possible in bereavement, and now I am." (p.3) Not only does personal experience benefit his own comprehension, but it also filters into his writing to give his readers an account which can reach them similarly. He writes Culture and Truth in an attempt to have his own experience permeate the discipline and have a voice within anthropology. He states, "My use of personal experience serves as a vehicle for

Ethnographic Research Design

1235 words - 5 pages realist ethnographies, critical ethnography does not concern itself with remaining unbiased instead the researcher in its tone truly reflects his or her thoughts about the matter as an activist would in demonstrations. By taking a stand, the researcher is able to “advocate for change to help transform our society” by taking into account those who are “oppressed and marginalized” (Creswell, 2008, p. 479). With this in mind, there are several

Examining the Views of Ethnographic Writers

1075 words - 4 pages used in fieldwork; her second examines the language employed in ethnographic descriptions. The connection of performance ethnography with the performance of writing presents an opportunity to examine the views of ethnographic writers. By applying Kisliuk’s argument to the ethnographic language of Aaron Fox (2004) and Cece Conway(1995) we gain insight into the (field) position(s) of the respective author. Aaron Fox’s ethnographic language in

Women's Rights

1827 words - 7 pages such as participant observation and ethnography have been used. Qualitative techniques are used when researcher conducts his observation based on words rather than numbers as it focuses more on interviews and group discussions. Even though this form of research provides an in depth analysis into the topping of discussion, it has certain disadvantages too, It has been criticized to be too subjective and are based on the researcher’s unsystematic

Evidence and Examples of the Four Learning Outcomes

2846 words - 12 pages of radio-frequency identification, I was able to identify and analyze the reason as to why I was presenting and writing an essay on the subject. I described to my audience the importance of radio-frequency identification through different rhetorical situations. Radio-Frequency Identification has made a positive aspect on people’s lives. Prior to writing the “Interview and Ethnography Assignment” I knew of my discourse community on a surface level

Semiautobiographical Work- Borderlands/La Frontera: The New Mestiza by Gloria Anzaldúa

1559 words - 6 pages critical ethnography. It focuses on the implied values expressed within ethnographic studies. “Critical ethnography begins with an ethical responsibility to address processes of unfairness or injustice within a particular lived domain” (Madison). These are the misunderstood biases that may result from implied values. Discourses can be either implicit or explicit. I would describe this as a form of telling the reader what the author wants them to know

Ethnography

1083 words - 4 pages Ethnography Works Cited Missing Reflexivity is a qualitative method of research that takes an ethnography one step further, displaying the personal thoughts and reflections of the anthropologist on his informants. Ethnographies generally take an outside or foreign perspective of a culture, like reading a text, and reflexivity introduces a new component of inside description. Here, the anthropologist may describe personal interactions and

Similar Essays

Historical Re Interpretations: Writing/Re Writing Of Ethnography And Historiography

2956 words - 12 pages the Ahom kingdom had just begun to establish itself as a prominent kingdom. In the novel, the ministers sent by the Kachari King Pratapdhwaj as an official embassy to the neighboring states and the detailed analysis of their first hand experiences on their return is the re-writing of historiography keeping in mind not only the demographic but also the cultural and social factors. Their narration is retelling lost history which in a way marks out

Collaborative Ethnography Essay

1662 words - 7 pages Introduction Postmodern anthropology can be described as a method to write about cultures in a certain way, by scrutinizing and interpreting the information gathered. Postmodern ethnographers believe that it is the way we interpret information that must be studied and that the voice of societies should be advocated through an informant. They also believe that to do this the use of collaborative ethnography is of vital importance. Collaborative

Ethnographic Research Essay

1967 words - 8 pages like process to discuss his experiences during his research in Morocco. This makes it easier for the reader to understand his ideas then just having a technical book about the many different aspects of Moroccan life that he may have discovered. In Writing Culture: the Poetics and Politics of Ethnography, edited by James Clifford and George E. Marcus, many of the different ideas of how an ethnographer should go about his or her research are

A Reflection On Ethnographies Essay

1447 words - 6 pages more serious, demanding tone. Whereas, Hedican’s ethnography is written for an audience of all age groups, and the tone of his writing is gentle and passionate, where people can relate to his experiences. However, I found similarities between ethnographies and journals, travel diaries, or even stories that you tell to your family and friends, because they all involve personal experiences that people can relate to which makes it more interesting to