Writing Performance Assessments: How Important Is Extended Time?

2147 words - 9 pages

Crawford, Helwig, and Tindalas research article, a Writing Performance Assessments: How Important is Extended Time examines the important question of whether or not students benefit from three day writing assessments as opposed to thirty minute assessments. The study examined general and special education students in the 5th grade and general education students in the 8th grade to determine if extended time benefited the students’ writings. This critique will examine the research article and offer insight into both the thirty minute and three day writing assessments while critically examining whether there was a basis for this type of study.
As large scale writing assessments becomes the standard for schools, the question is posed of how good writing can be defined and how can valid samples of writing ability be collected. (Page 132) Adding students with learning disabilities into this equation also serves to complicate the matter by introducing a group that is more likely to interject personal commentary, less likely to write coherently, and all too often are unable to successfully transfer their thoughts on to paper. It has been conclusively proven that students with learning disabilities score significantly lower in writing assessments when compared to their general education peers. Therefore, one might assume that extended time would certainly benefit students with learning disabilities and might possibly help those in general education as well. However, researchers have not always found that extended time benefits the writing compositions of students.
Theoretically, when extended time is given, students should be able to engage themselves in all four stages of the writing process: planning, writing, revising and rewriting (Page 133). These stages, when done properly, are fluid, moving from one stage to the next. When an elementary-age student writing was examined, researchers found little difference between the first drafts and those that had been revised. Rather, most researchers noted that it was the older students who benefited from extended time, but even their score were not significantly altered by the extra time. In fact, one study even concluded that students did not seem to use the entire allotted time, regardless of how long they were given. Another study concluded that the difference between original and revised drafts was improved handwriting quality.
Crawford, Helwig, and Tindal undertake this study in part because little research in writing compositions has included students with learning disabilities, and also to put to rest the question of whether extended time benefits writing compositions of students. The study was conducted with 213 Grade 5 students and 140 Grade 8 students located in the Pacific Northwest. The Grade 5 sample included 42 students with learning disabilities and 2 students with mental retardation. The Grade 8 sample included 6 students with learning disabilities, which the researchers concluded was not a...

Find Another Essay On Writing Performance Assessments: How Important is Extended Time?

Communication and How Important It Is

930 words - 4 pages being taught to you to make you stronger for the future. How you look at that lesson no matter the situation, will determine how much you have learned and grown from that moment in time. With that being said, use the ability to communicate and your thought process to receive what you are in search of. Understanding your mind and the process of your conscious and subconscious thoughts and, most importantly, what effect they have is a powerful thing

How important is discipline in society?

3042 words - 12 pages sections or age groups of the population statistically most likely to commit crimes and would no doubt institute curfews. Yet we have reservations about measures such as these because as well as freedom from crimes, we value other things like freedom of speech, of movement and association. In this light, punishment as a means of discipline is important in society.At the same time, this importance can be diminished in the view of the adverse effects of

Is the physical consistency of web interface design important in terms of user performance and satisfation?

2342 words - 10 pages important from the user’s perspective. Ozok and Salvendy’s investigation (2000) found that out of the three groups, physical consistency is most effective in terms of user performance, assessed by faster task completion, less clicking, faster navigation and less reading errors made by users (Ozok & Salvendy, 2000) . Studies show that the visual appearance of a web site has a major effect on user satisfaction and how users appreciate the web site

How Important Is Class Size In Determining Successful Academic Achievement?

547 words - 2 pages Students are always pursuing successful academic achievement, which is influenced by many factors. Among these, class size has recently been mentioned more and more. Some people hold that the smaller the class is, the higher scores the students get. But class size may not be the main factor in determining successful academic achievement. There are many other important factors which contribute to the students’ satisfactory academic performance

How Important is Expert Opinion in The Search for Knowledge?

1420 words - 6 pages populace always depend on their leaders for information. The community believes and accepts the tribe leaders or village chief as their chief source for reliable knowledge. Opinions from the leaders is sacred and the most powerful, and significant opinion for decision making and problem solving. Expert opinion is still an important source for knowledge. However, the nature for appointment of expert opinion changes from time to time, and

How Important is a Drama Ministry Team for Your Church?

1421 words - 6 pages ). However, theatre in the church is often only used for special occasions such as Easter, Advent, and Christmas. If drama in the church is believed to be an effective way of engaging congregation, it could be asked why it is not used more regularly as a part of the sermons. And second, if it did become an integral part of the ministry, how important would it be to develop a good model and an effective leadership team to run it? People in the church

How important is Larry Lasalle to the novel?

633 words - 3 pages the novel, we are often led to wonder how important Larry Lasalle really is to the novel. We will examine three aspects of his involvement in the novel, and discover that he is indeed a crucial element. Exploring his role in maintaining conflict throughout the story, his part in triggering the rising actions as well as the way his presence influences the development of the other characters. Larry Lasalle helps to maintain an air of conflict

How Important is the Mentor Teacher to the Student Teacher?

3005 words - 12 pages 2. Introduction a. Problem statement / Research problem (Question 2) Over the course of their degree studies, student teachers gain valuable theorical knowledge of teaching without really understanding how this knowledge will be practically applied once they enter the classroom for the first time. This is why teaching practicals are of paramount importance: student teachers are afforded an opportunity to put their theory into practice within a

How Important is Creativity in the World Market?

1904 words - 8 pages society where they can be responsive, fulfilled and innovative. The ability to use methods of teaching and learning within the curriculum is important when trying to make it possible. Countless amounts of schools have already been familiarising themselves with the importance of creativity and ways of how to teach, how to make the learning more holistic, more engaging and more creative. With the new curriculum complete, there are consequently many

The Essay Is About Tradititions And How They Are Important

532 words - 3 pages Dion PurchasPeriod 7The Analysis of TraditionTradition is used all over the world. Tradition is something that a lot of people believe in. Some people like to celebrate different events and do different things. Some people don't like to do the same thing all the time. They like to change things. Well I'm here to talk about how tradition is good and bad. In the short storyThe Lottery they talk about tradition. I will explain what their tradition

How is civil society important for democracy in Kyrgyzstan?

1577 words - 6 pages Aisalkyn AlimbaevaResearch PaperPolitics of KyrgyzstanHow is civil society important for democracy in Kyrgyzstan?In my research paper I want to analyze how civil society in reality is important for democracy. In modern way of understanding, democracy is a type of government, which cannot exist without right of the people, where individual is not a subject of the government but where "government of the people, by the people and for the people

Similar Essays

Writing Style Is Important Essay

1526 words - 6 pages Writing Style is Important Before expounding on the elements and forms of style, there are two main questions that should be asked: What is style, and why should one be concerned with it? In answer to the first question, I believe that style is choice. One’s style is determined by the types of words he chooses, and the diction with which he displays them. A style can be casual or formal, simple or verbose; every time an author writes

How Important Is Performance Space To Performance, Give Reference To Two Performances You Have Seen

1097 words - 4 pages How important is performance space to performance? The question of performance space's importance in conveying meaning and guiding audience response is complicated. First we must define the term "performance space". In a broader sense, it can refer to venue, which in the case of site-specific artists such as Shunt, means performance space is indeed central to the construction and context of meaning. Venues also come with their own sets of

How Important Is Being Earnest? Essay

1577 words - 6 pages they are only thinking about themselves. The lives of all the characters mingle together all due to this one character named Ernest who is first created by the character, Jack, for personal benefit. Ernest is spelled different from the word “earnest” which means serious in purpose or sincerity of feelings. Wilde uses this play on words to create a satire on the morals of people during his time period. The characters in the novel do not display

How Important Is Diversity In A Company

2723 words - 11 pages adaptation5. Handle a problemSo many differences in company and this are difficult to manager to analyse one by one what happen in companies, according to diversity manager can do this process if that company have a problem.1. Get Clear on the Problem; The first step in solving a problem is to analyze what is happening. What changes are occurring in the environment your company does business in, and how important are they? What exactly is the problem?2