Writing Processes In Education Essay

1126 words - 5 pages

It may seem that teaching methods would change as often as the students as each year welcomes a new set of unique personalities and backgrounds. However, this is not the case. Teaching approaches generally tend to happen in shifts as new studies reveal more effective means of reaching students. A popular trend among writing programs is to adopt what is being called the process approach to writing instruction. This is a very different approach from the old form of teaching which is called the product approach. To help the writing school determine which approach would be more effective for our students, it is necessary to know a bit more about each of these approaches before making a recommendation.
The assumption under the product school of writing is that writing, like any other skill, can be taught. By giving students proper and rigorous instruction in language usage and basic principles of writing, it is suggested they will be able to then be able to start producing high quality essays and research papers entirely on their own (Hairston, 1996). Using this approach, instructors use sample texts and ask the students to mimic the processes they see in the book, such as the traditional 5-paragraph essay. Grammar and rules are very important in this approach and a strong message is sent that the first draft is the final draft and the only draft that matters (Hairston, 1996). Creative exercises are seen as a waste of time because they tend to break the rules the teacher is trying so hard to enforce. Not surprisingly, the teacher is the guiding force in the classroom with the students simply doing as they are told.
This approach is most helpful when students are learning about how to write mostly formulaic-type work, such as business reports or cover letters. It helps students identify poor grammar structure early in the process at the same time that it gives them a relatively predictable structure on which to build as they face complicated academic writing assignments. However, using this approach doesn't usually produce quality work. According to Eschholz (1980), such an approach will only result in "mindless copies of a particular organizational plan or style" (24). It has often been described as habit formation (Silva, 1990: 13). "Writing is messy, recursive, convoluted and uneven" (Hairston, 1982: 85), but the product approach with its focus on mimicry, ignores these characteristics of writing and can quickly set up students for failure.
The process school, on the other hand, operates with the assumption that the skill of writing can only be acquired gradually. Rather than drilling students with the rules and conventions of writing, this school holds that it is better to allow students to develop their writing through a slow evolution of working with the instructor and other students in a process called peer review (Eschholz, 1980). In fact, the concept of collaboration is considered to be an important tool in learning to write. It more...

Find Another Essay On Writing Processes in Education

Children's Emergent Writing Essay

2636 words - 11 pages function throughout the early years.In the recent years, we have seen a great deal of increase in interest in writing processes. (Beard 2000)This has encouraged practitioners to give much more thought about how and why children write. In building upon these developments however, it is important to understand the importance of the early foundations on which these writing processes are built upon.Traditional teaching approaches towards the hope to


1461 words - 6 pages of trained peer response on ESL students' revision types and writing quality. Journal of Second Language Writing, 8(3), 215-241. Bijami, M., Kashef, S. H., & Nejah, M. S. (2013). Peer feedback in learning English writing: Advantages and Disadvantages. Journal of Studies in Education, 3, 91-97. Grönkvist, J. (2006). Peer Response in Upper Secondary School: Do Swedish students find it useful for improving their English writing skills? Karlstad

Introduction and Rationale

1870 words - 7 pages , the level of education and language proficiency is related to the degree that researchers are able to validate the presence of separate reading and writing subskills. For example, when dealing with a group of absolute beginners, a measurement tool will not indicate any difference in ability between a variety of advanced literacy subskills since all the learners in the study have zero ability in those subskills. As such, a researcher would conclude


1235 words - 5 pages society there are literally thousands of ways a person could be educated, meaning there is no single definition. Although people that society considers truly educated share similar characteristics such as the ability to read, write and use technology, education cannot be specifically defined.Most people would agree that reading and writing are fundamentals that one must have in order to be considered educated. Some may consider speaking a sign of

The Purpose of writing within the context of Schooling.

1346 words - 5 pages . It's also an important part of the process of writing self-correction and self-evaluation. Students take a responsible role in their own learning processes. It also gives optimum opportunities for student's assessment when the teacher is able to see the learnt process collaborated.In summary the place of writing in the Primary school curriculum is to enable students to construct text that meet social and real life purposes. It allows students to

The Education for All Handicapped Children Act

1451 words - 6 pages secured the fundamental ideals, rights and responsibilities to ascertain equal access to public education for all children who are disabled. It helped the students with their education and gave them the rights they deserved. What education has done in the years it has been around is that it simply makes life one sizably extensive, perplexed system of steps and processes. Our schools don’t accommodate the goal of a true education, but it makes it appear

Functionalism Theory of Education

1389 words - 6 pages socialization, primary schools sort people according to their general level of ability; secondary schools begin the process of specialization in specific abilities and, accordingly, direct some to work and others on to further education. Education is important in society; the structure and processes of education systems are related to the general process of socialization (Van Krieken 2000, p.191). Many sociologists may agree with this statement, but

Writing: Art Vs. Science

687 words - 3 pages writing, then let his words describe his expressions.In writing, the author must find a balance between scientific and artistic writing. The message of the writing must be extractable by the reader, but must also be enjoyable. In Instead of Introduction: Write on! the author explains ""¦all kinds of writing share two important characteristics: they result from deeply personal, natural thought processes, and they take on widely public, conventional forms." Although scientific writing and artistic writing can be seen as opposites, they compliment each other to the point that one could not exist without the other.

My Philosophy of Education

805 words - 3 pages . They learn to write by writing. Listening to and talking about literature enhances both processes. Children learn to think, to question, to reflect on what they write, read, and listen to in a classroom that allots a significant amount of time to the interaction and practice of these skills. Children make choices as to what to read, what to write, and how to approach a task. These children who make their own decisions take ownership of

Quality Individualized Educational Programs

1419 words - 6 pages support, and supplementary aids and services. A needed service provided in an education setting to support a child with an IEP could be large print books for students with visual disabilities (Gibb&Dyches, 2007, p.70). During this fourth step of the IEP processes it is important students are placed in the least restrictive environment (LRE). This setting is most important and could possibly place students with disabilities in classes, with

Tele-education – blessing or curse?

1581 words - 6 pages demerits for this phenomenon. There is much evidence that tele-education can be more cost-effective than traditional teaching method. In Petters's writing (1994), he examines the structure of tele-education and discovers the option of using tele-education to implement economies of scale and decrease unit costs. To administrators, tele-education is alluring because it can lower the costs and help their institutions modernize and "get-digital

Similar Essays

Explain The Importance Of Modelled Writing In The Primary English Classroom

839 words - 3 pages offers maximum support from the teacher, with the opportunity for students to observe and understand how to: choose a topic, organise and sequence their information, draft, proofread and edit, and use different forms, processes and conventions across the curriculum. It illustrates how different texts are structured, and involves students in the process of writing through talking, questioning and reading. (Evans, 1991, 282 Reader, 261).The benefit to

Students With Adhd Essay

2383 words - 10 pages more. Writing samples of ADHD students when compared with general education students’ show that ADHD students tend to write shorter compositions that are lower in quality and show more errors (p. 158). In addition, due to an impairment of higher-level brain functions needed to regulate, focus, plan, elaborate, manage emotions, etc., ADHD students frequently leave out required elements in their writing (p. 158). Experts recommend several

Adequacy Of High School English Writing Program. "Explaining A Concept"

515 words - 2 pages of high school courses provides students with the best preparation for College work. It can give them a definite edge in their undergraduate studies and the opportunity to do advanced preparation for their chosen field of study. The purpose of these programs is to improve student-writing skill."Students need to learn how to use language to communicate in different ways and for multiple purposes. Threrfore, the processes of reading, writing

Journals, Reflection, And Learning Essay

2206 words - 9 pages demands time and space for reflection, encourages independent thought and ownership, enables expression of feelings, and provides a place to work with ill-structured problems. . Reflection encourages deep rather than surface learning. English and Gillen (2001) report a dearth of research on the effectiveness of journal writing in adult education, although a few studies have demonstrated changes in thinking (Jasper 1999