This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Yin And Yang: The Nature Of Scientific Explanation In A Culture

3648 words - 15 pages

Yin and Yang: the Nature of Scientific Explanation in a Culture

ABSTRACT: I explore the nature of scientific explanation in a culture centering on the doctrine of yin and yang combined with that of five phrases, wu-hsing (YYFP). I note how YYFP functions as an alternative to the causal way of thinking, as well as the meaning of scientific explanation in a culture. I also consider whether a scientific concept becomes metaphorical when it is superseded by an alternative organizing concept.

To a Western eye, or even to a contemporary Eastern eye, many explanations given under the doctrine of yin and yang combined with that of five phases (wu-hsing), apparently intended to be scientific, would seem either absurd or too arbitrary at first sight. An intriguing fact, however, is that the doctrine of yin and yang and that of five phases (hereafter YYFP) has prevailed until quite recently in almost all the areas of Far-Eastern cultures including medicine, astronomy, music, dance, architecture, geomancy.

In this essay, I pay attention to the questions such as how YYFP functioned as an alternative to the causal way of thinking, and what it is to be a scientific or theoretical explanation in a culture. I also consider the question of whether a scientific concept becomes metaphorical when it is superseded by an alternative organizing concept. Let me begin with the development of the concept of YYFP, as you may not know in the first place what YYFP is.

Until around the 4th century B.C., yin and yang were current words for "sunshine" and "shade" and were used separately from the five phases of change. Soon after, they came to be included in the six ch'i (six powers or forces) of Heaven. The six ch'i refer to wind, rain, dark, light, yin and yang. Yin and yang as parts of the six ch'i are now powers that would balance the order of nature inducing proper seasonal changes and controlling precipitation or wind.

And yet, it was not until the Warring States (403-222 B.C.) that yin and yang became two opposing forces generating everything in the universe. The concepts of yin and yang as two fundamental forces are most conspicuous in I Ching (the Book of Changes) being epitomized in the statement, "The successive movement of yin and yang constitutes the Way (Tao)" ("Commentary on the Appended Phrases", part I, ch. 5). As they settled into the categories of opposing forces, they came to provide an explanatory apparatus applicable to opposites, contraries, and hierarchical pairs. For instance, heaven, sun, fire, flying, running, being round, and male, on the one hand, belong with the force of yang; earth, moon, water, hibernating, hiding, being square, and female, on the other hand, belong with the force of yin.

The supposed explanatory power of yin and yang grew enormously when combined with the doctrine of the five phases. The doctrine of the five phases provides a system where everything is categorized into one of five groups. Everything in the...

Find Another Essay On Yin and Yang: the Nature of Scientific Explanation in a Culture

Tying Together Yin, Yang, Dao, and the Chinese Dream of Golden Age

2057 words - 9 pages 1/ Explain the concepts of “Yin” and “Yang”. Using pp. 227 ff in the textbook, try to tie them together with an early understanding of the “Dao” (“Tao”) and the Chinese dream of a ‘Golden Age’. The concepts of Yin, Yang, and Dao are beliefs the early Chinese had to better understand the order of nature and its elements. Yang is male energy, and is understood to stand for dry and warm elements in nature, as well as for active and expansive

A Scientific Explanation of Stem Cells and Stem Cell Research

562 words - 2 pages In general, a cell can be defined as a stem cell if two basic criteria are met. First, stem cell is capable of self renewal for indefinite period throughout life while maintaining undifferentiated state, i.e., the cell can divide and produce two identical daughter cells and thereby maintains the stem cell pool. Second, stem cell possesses capacity for differentiate into specialised and functional progeny under the right conditions, or given the

The branches, nature and importance of philosophy as a scientific descipline

1571 words - 6 pages IntroductionI am going to describe the nature of philosophy and show its importance as a scientific discipline. I will list some of its branches and explain the part of philosophy they deal with. This in turn will describe the subject matter of philosophy as a whole.The word philosophy is derived from two Greek words: philo and sophia. The former means love, while the latter means wisdom. Therefore, the word philosophy simply means love of

Scientific Explanation of Paranbormal Phenomena

1023 words - 5 pages and history. To many individuals it’s a touchy subject even skeptic have claimed to have an idea of the unexplained events. Paranormal phenomena is inconsistent with scientific explanation. However, empirical observation has made it somewhat concrete to both now ex skeptics and original believers. The true story behind the film the Exorcism of Emily Ross is both fascinating and terrifying. The first documented timeline took place in Wateska, IL

The scientific explanation for the existence of Vampires

1714 words - 7 pages feared a creature similar to a vampire known as anEkimmu. These creatures known as Ekimmus were believed by the Assyrians to roam theplanet searching for food although it was not always a persons blood but rather a persons'vitality or that persons' energy force. It was believed that if such a creature would entersomeone's house that person along with his or her family would slowly weaken, get sickand probably die. In the countries of Syria and

Humans and Nature during the Scientific Revolution

1332 words - 5 pages even on those who realized Descartes’ own shortcomings. 2 Since nature came to be seen as something completely mechanical, people began to believe that mathematics could be used to find an explanation for all natural phenomena. Thus, scientists made use of mathematics instead of metaphysics and theology in their study of nature. The Scientific Revolution also showed man to be merely a small part of a larger divine plan. Man no longer found

Human Beings and Nature: The Scientific Revolution

1834 words - 7 pages attitudes and skepticism of old views on nature and humanity was a slow process that spanned over a two century period. During the Scientific Revolution, scientific knowledge enabled humans to control nature in order to improve society. With leaders such as Nicolaus Copernicus, Galileo Galilei, Francis Bacon, Isaac Newton, and Rene Descartes, the Scientific Revolution proves to be a crucial piece to the puzzle of understanding the effects of humansí

Comparison and conclusions about the nature of knowledge between knowing a friend and knowing how to swim, knowing a scientific theory and knowing a historical period

1037 words - 4 pages some of the ways we learn and interact with the world. We have to learn to obtain or achieve things in our life like, finding a friend, learning how to swim, proving a scientific theory, or to write or tell an historical period. We learn to know, therefore by learning we gain knowledge, we learn everyday and from everything, so the nature of knowledge is non-stop learning. Having this non-stop learning is a way that we can survive in the world around us. Knowledge helps us to survive in this nature. Last, to learn means to survive and continue your survival and further on we will or may be prosperous.

Mutations in Nature and Culture

761 words - 3 pages Mutations in Nature and Culture Many other words, both positive and negative, spring to mind when one hears the word "mutation." In a scientific sense, one might think of the random variations that lead to evolution in species. In a sci-fi/ horror flick sense, one might think of a vicious monster that after contact with some radioactive substance became terribly disfigured. But rarely do we associate mutations with ideas pervasive to our

Short description and explanation of Forensics in the legal system

545 words - 2 pages According to, forensics is "the use of science and technology to investigate and establish facts in criminal or civil courts of law." In fact, forensics science plays the strongest role in solving any crime. There are a variety of methods involved with solving crimes; the main two are witness accounts and forensics evidence.Witness accounts and other human dependability prove to be inferior to the power of forensics science. There

The Nature of Scientific Progress as described in T.H. Kuhn's model of paradigms and revolutions, and Larry Laudan's model of research traditions

2147 words - 9 pages understanding of progress in terms of science and culture are T.H. Kuhn's model of paradigms and revolutions, and Larry Laudan's model of research traditions. If science is viewed in a naïve sense, where every theory is just a logical continuation of the previous one and the nature of change is frequent and gradual, then progress is easy to see because each new theory is simply better then its forerunner. While this may hold true in some cases where

Similar Essays

The Yin And Yang Of Identity

1651 words - 7 pages her name correctly. The opposition causes the audience to realize Ruth’s trouble in maintaining the two. Ruth’s own father wants her to be an “All-American” kid, while her own mother exposes Ruth to Japanese culture. Both work in unison by the end of the documentary though, creating a balanced yin and yang relationship. Though one might argue that Ozeki instead rejects her American identity by only bringing up her father’s influence on her life at

Yin And Yang Of True Love’s Passion

1189 words - 5 pages even more movie tickets is of glamour and charm. Like the romances portrayed in the movies, Cathy and Heathcliff’s love is boundless and impregnable, proving to be stronger than a single strand of spider silk. Although many threaten to cut the strand, including Edgar Linton, it is invincible. No one can interfere, especially Edgar, because in both Catherine and Heathcliff’s mind, they love each other more than anyone could ever imagine: “If he

The Yin Yang School Essay

2563 words - 10 pages has. When I sit back and look at it from a distance, there is a perfect line that can be drawn up the trunk of the tree, and when that line is discovered, there is a perfect balance in the tree. The tree is nature, and the building is man, and though they are competing for the same space at the same time, there appears to be an understanding between the two of them. This balance that lies within this single tree is what the Chinese yin-yang

Yin And Yang Essay

2069 words - 9 pages reflects my outward belief and trust in communism, as it is my idea of utopia. Deep down inside, I feel that no colors accompany my inner being. Usually, I feel that the inside of me is just filled with intangible concepts like optimism and dreams, so I don't think colors are part of them. Obviously, my artwork is divided into two sides. I also feel like the sides of yin and yang are within me, but never in perfect balance. The right