Do You Think That The Courts Should Have A Statutory Discretion To Determine The Effects Of Illegality In Resulting Trust Cases?

1725 words - 7 pages

Do you think that the courts should have a statutory discretion to determine the effects of illegality in resulting trust cases?There is much debate and discussion amongst many commentators in relation to illegality and whether the courts should have a statutory discretion to determine the effects of it in resulting trust cases. It is clear that there is a great deal of confusion, uncertainly and complexity relating to this area, particularly in relation to the maxim 'he who comes to equity must come with clean hands'.# An area of much controversy has arisen in relation to where the presumption of a resulting trust appears to collide with the principle that equity does not assist a person with unclean hands. There have been a number of important cases in relation to this, with somewhat conflicting decisions, for the purpose of this essay, only a few important cases will be discussed as it would be impossible and impractical to discuss all the cases in this area.The House of Lords case, Tinsley v. Milligan# highlights the need, suggested by many commentators, that reform is needed in this area. In this particular case, a house was brought with the money provided by two women, but was only put into the name of one of the women (the claimant) so that the other woman (the defendant) could claim housing benefit. The defendant claimed that the property was held for her on a resulting trust by virtue of her contributions. Dunnington# notes the issue here was the conduct which the defendant had to rely on to support her claim of resulting trust. If it was her fraud then she could not claim a resulting trust, however, here she only had to rely on her contributions to the purchase price and so her claim succeeded as her fraud was, as a matter of evidence, irrelevant.The decision of the House of Lords in Tinsley v. Milligan# has been powerfully criticised. It has been noted in Hanbury and Martin# that as a result of this decision it has been said to be that "He who comes to equity should keep unclean hands in his pockets." Indeed commentators such as Buckley# subscribe to this view, however, others such as Enonchong seem to lean towards a different view stating "Tinsley v Milligan# is a spectacular manifestation of the diversity of current judicial opinion on this most confused and confusing branch of the law. Learned judges in the court of Appeal and the House of Lords have had great difficulty in formulating a general satisfactory principle and have been obliged to reach different conclusions."Hanbury and Martin# note that the decision in Tinsley v. Milligan has been applied by the Court of Appeal in Sliverwood v. Sliverwood# in this case, the deceased (Daisy Sliverwood) had withdrawn a capital sum from her bank, and given it to her grandchildren before claiming income support. On her death her son, the executor claimed that the children held the money on a resulting trust for Daisy. Applying Tinsley v. Milligan his claim was upheld, although if the money...

Find Another Essay On Do you think that the courts should have a statutory discretion to determine the effects of illegality in resulting trust cases?

When you read the constitution do you think that it is a democratic plan for government?

579 words - 2 pages , IV, and VI of the constitution, it says "he" several times. "He" should not be said because a woman could also be in one of the elected chairs of the government. Is the constitution not allowing a woman to be in the same spot as men in the government? If that is the case, then women would be second-class citizens, because they would not have the same opportunities as men do. The constitution left the power of each state government to decide who

What do you think to be the significance of the Albatross in "The Ancient Mariner"?

1032 words - 4 pages all things are one?Each of the interpretation reflects the recognition of a tripartite movement in the poem. Each interpretation represents the journey out, the trail and revelation, and the journey back (Holmes), and this is what the Albatross, to me, signifies.However we look at it, we can not deny the significance of the Albatross, whether it be just one of God's creation or something more supernatural, Coleridge certainly left it open for the reader to decide. It is also here which I should note that the occurrence of the albatross symbolises different ideas and beliefs throughout the poem, and therefore being of significance.

Do you think that it is morally acceptable to have preferential treatment programs for disabled veterans?

951 words - 4 pages court order (respectively) to settle discrimination lawsuits that involved preferential hiring or promotion of minority groups.In all of the above cases, the Court was narrowly divided in 5-4 or 6-3 decisions. The decisions were also closely reasoned on a case-by-case basis. General legal principles had to be extracted carefully.Another closely divided decision, but one which some legal scholars have argued can be interpreted broadly, was Johnson

To what extent do you think the modern world faces a 'dictatorship of relativism'?

1128 words - 5 pages power to create inequalities. Globally, twenty percent of the world's people in the highest-income countries account for eighty-six percent of total private consumption expenditures whilst the poorest twenty percent account for a minuscule 1.3%. The poor are so because the rich are wealthy and have the power to enforce unequal trade agreements that favour their interests more than the poorer nations. Many wealthy nations are tied to opening up

What do the texts you have studied have to say about the positive and/or negative effects of institutions?

1131 words - 5 pages individual. It shows us how the fight for power within this institution can prove to be fatal, but the positive is that Brett achieved what he was aiming for.After analysis of the above, it can be concluded that the institution has many influences on an individual, both positive and negative in nature. It's the lessons that are taken out of these experiences that determine the true effect that it can have. Institutions such as the farm consist of a

Do you think that the concept of organisational culture is a useful one in the real world? If so, why? If not, why not?

3912 words - 16 pages management, renaming business units and redeploying functions will have minimal positive effects on organisational culture and may indeed have negative implications expressed in frustration and cynicism, if order and development is not allow to prevail once the 'dust settles'.Culture therefore should be viewed longitudinal over time as a dynamic and organic process and not as a static entity that can be cross-sectioned. As Bate has shown

Do you think that the monster in Frankenstein deserves our sympathy? Why or Why not?

1069 words - 4 pages is that the monster did not even have a name. He did not have a place in society, no place for him to fit in. He did not have an identity, his existence is not defined by who he is, but by the things he did. From the time since he’s born, the monster did not reappear until the news of the murder was announced to the readers. The monster eventually will never have a name, never to be accepted by the society.I think that the monster's

Do you agree that abortion should be legal under circumstances or mothers should have the right to abortion as they wish?

1248 words - 5 pages Do you agree that abortion should be legal under circumstances or mothers should have the right to abortion as they wish?Why should abortion be legalised? A number of Controversial arguments about problems of abortion have been discussed seriously in many countries over hundreds of years. For example, Ireland and Texas have just passed the law and restrictions respectively relating to abortion after lengthy heated discussion. It is a very

Do you think that advertising should be restricted? Why? What form(s) should this restriction take? could be a speech

696 words - 3 pages Do you think that advertising should be restricted? Why? What form(s) should this restriction take?Advertising is beginning to dominate today's society, brainwashing young, vulnerable viewers. Advertising has and will affect everyone, whether it's a new facial wash on a TV advert or the latest mobile phone on a billboard, each uses the same manipulation technique to persuade the viewer. Advertising has always affected people of many ages in both

"Why do you think the U.S. was the last nation in the industrialized world to permit the institution of slavery?"

693 words - 3 pages taxation without representation.' With all this in mind, why do you think the U.S. was the last nation in the industrialized world to permit the institution of slavery?Essay:Slavery has been a problem since the beginning of time. So why should the American colonies be any different? Slavery was introduced into the "new world" in 1606, and it grew rapidly in the south until the time of the revolutionary war in 1775. It then continued until 1865

Explain briefly Ninian Smart's seven dimensional model of religion. Do you think that Smart's model solves the problems that arise when attempting to define religion?

1161 words - 5 pages practice vary so do the religious experience. The enlightenment of the Buddha, the visionary experiences of Muhammad and the suffering of Christ, all generate strong emotions within the religious individual, giving meaning to the rituals they perform in their honour. For example, breaking bread for Christians would have no meaning if it did not represent the sacrifice of Jesus. Sharp also says that music is a powerful form of expression for many

Similar Essays

The Courts Should Not Have The Right To Make Legislation That The Majority Of People Do Not Approve Of

680 words - 3 pages courts should not have the right to make legislation that the majority of people do not approve of. When interpreting the Constitution, one must consider its originalism. That is, you must consider the author's original intent in writing it. Thomas Jefferson, an author of the Constitution, favored the will of the majority of people. "Not only does majority rule ensure that the least number of people are going to be dissatisfied, but the

"Do You Think There Are Any Authors Or Books Not Listed In The `chicago Canon` That Should Definitely Not Have Been Omitted? Discuss" Socrates

562 words - 2 pages principles even though they ultimately cost him his life.To my surprise Socrates was not mentioned on the `Chicago Canon` list, while he definitely should not have been omitted, for he was the most mysterious figure in all history of philosophy. Despite having written nothing, Socrates (470 – 399 BC), is considered to be one of the most influential thinkers in Europe. He is customarily regarded as the father of political philosophy and ethics

Do You Think That All Sub/Counter Cultures Have A Right To Exist?

725 words - 3 pages Many cultures coming from history experiences have their own set of rules to obey by and I think these beliefs are correct to them. In my opinion I would like for all good cultures to exist, many people think of cultures as an organization but it can be a good thing and not something of waste. Today in modern society one will assume that cultures are a waste of time and that is completely understandable because the technology of today can do

Discuss How You Feel About The Form Of Discrimination They Explore In Their Poem, What Effect Do You Think They Are Trying To Have On You As A Reader?

1239 words - 5 pages discrimination. People may not like one another, but they respect each other. He makes us think about the ways that we can change our actions, so that we can achieve a future free from discrimination. "Nobody'll dare say to me `eat in the kitchen then," (lines 11-14). He made the people of his time think about a future that was completely different from the present. He makes us think about change, which in 1924 was thought to be dangerous