Young Irish Women And Sex In Seamus Heaney's Poem, Punishment, And In The Documentary, Sex In A Cold Climate

2697 words - 11 pages

During the 20th century in Ireland, girls had to suppress their inner-sexual thoughts and desires becasue Irish girls' personal lives were dictated and controlled by the Catholic church and state. Ireland socially accepted female inferiority as they humiliated and tortured young girls for loving another partner. As seen in Seamus Heaney's poem, Punishment, and the documentary, Sex in a Cold Climate, Irish girls' views of love and sex were forever tainted because of the public treatment and ridicule they received. In Punishment, Heaney describes a personal experience witnessing a young girl tarred-and-feathered in public for loving a British solider. Moreover, Sex in a Cold Climate focuses on four women and their tragic experiences in Ireland's Magdalene Asylums. Furthermore drawing themes from Punishment and Sex in a Cold Climate, I am going to discuss the relationship between sexual desires and punishment and argue that Irish girls were deprived of having a normal love and sex life.
In Seamus Heaney's Punishment (1975), recalls a specific yet terrible moment in his life.
The Irish rebellion against Britain remained significant to nationalism to Ireland and Irish people; moreover, to those who betray Ireland were severely chastised. According to Enda Duffy, Heaney observed a young women, naked and bald, ready to be hanged in front of the church where she was being tarred and penalized for being enamored with a British solider (Duffy 4/6/10). Heaney calls this woman a “little adultress” and “[his] scapegoat” to show the woman's betrayal to her country (Heaney ln 23, 28). This situation is biased because of the soldier's nationality: if the solider was Irish, the couple would be socially acceptable but because the solider was British, the girl is being sentenced to death. The war and rivalry between Ireland and Britain is strong enough to interfere with interpersonal relationships of the innocent. Additionally, the woman mentioned in the poem is being berated for being in loved, the most incorruptible and pleasurable feelings one could experience. Because fraternizing with the British is seen as a crime, women do not have any control of their own lives. By witnessing the young girl's moments before death, Heaney illustrates how the Irish rebellion affected many people.
Although the focus of Punishment is on Heaney's past experience, it is also associates with Peter Glob's finding of a dead woman within a Danish bog. Women were pressured to abide by “society's sexual norms” dictated by the Church and State which believes that woman must be pure and virginal (Crowley and Kitchi 364). But in in the third and fourth stanza, Heaney states:
“I can see her drowned
body in the bog,
the weighing stone,
the floating rods and boughs.
Under which at first
she was a barked sapling
that is dug up
oak-bone, brain-firkin,”
an image that countbalances society's norms (Heaney ln 9-16). According to Enda Duffy, bogs or turfs...

Find Another Essay On Young Irish Women and Sex in Seamus Heaney's Poem, Punishment, and in the Documentary, Sex in a Cold Climate

Men, Women, and Sex Differences Essay

2568 words - 10 pages Men, Women, and Sex Differences *Missing Works Cited* Nature vs. Nurture? The debate has obsessed the minds of psychologists and philosophers for many years, each arguing their idea is the right way. ABC aired a TV documentary "Boys and Girls are Different" hosted by John Stossel to show some of the leading feminists ideas and their opponents thoughts. Psychologist, and researcher from the Kinsey Institute, June M. Reinisch believes

Recognising the distinction between sex and gender is vital, in order to comprehend structured social inequality between both men and women

1484 words - 6 pages roles in society. Marxist feminists are slightly different in their view of exploitation. They agree that men play a large part in exercising power over women, however capitalism is the main source. They would argue that although the socialisation of children into their gender roles does benefit men, it benefits the capitalists more. By encouraging young girls to play with dolls, cook and clean etc, is endorsing women's role of becoming a housewife

Selling of young children for sex in another country. "Children As Commodities"

7757 words - 31 pages people to talk about the trafficking of women and children because of the underlying sexual component. We have to break that silence."Only then, perhaps, will young girls stop feeling as one did after her initiation into the sex trade: "The first day someone slept with me, I felt as if God had died.""Slaves To Lust"by Lesley DownerThe Sunday Times, Weekend MagazineJuly 18, 1999Underage Nepalese girls are a valuable commodity in India: they are

Sex and Love Throughout Time Compares movie "Dangerous Liasons" and ancient Greek poem "Birth Control"

2011 words - 8 pages Sex and Love Throughout TimeIn society sex is an issue that is looked upon different ways by different people. This has been valid in today's age and ancient times. When you are younger you are told sex is an act you do not perform until you are older and more mature. When you are older you are then suppose to wait for the right person. Some people view it as being sacred. Others view it as a game. The poem "Birth Control" and the movie

Language and Sex. Sex differences in language.

2977 words - 12 pages only appropriate for use by women and others that only men can use (unless a speaker of one sex is quoting a member of the other). In some cases, these kinds of difference depend not only on the speaker's sex, but of both the speaker and the addressee.List of References------------------KEY, M.R.(1975)Male/ Female Language (Metuchen: The Scarecrow Press)LAKOFF, R.(1975)Language and Woman's Place, (New York et. al.: Harper and Row)SACHS,J

"Sex is easy to find. Commitment is easy to avoid. Childlessness among well-educated women is on the rise. Relationships are on the nose." Discuss making families in the new millennium.

2026 words - 8 pages flaws when the relationship is on permanent trial. In any case, we now marry or avoid marriage for many more reasons than we did in the days when marriage was an acceptable passport to sex, or respectability, or security for women.Besides the changing idea of the young people, the increasing market productivity of women is the other main reason for the dropping marriage rate, women are earning more and have less incentive to marry for financial

Sex Education in the U.S. and Japan

1464 words - 6 pages provided in the U.S and Japan, comprehensive sex education is the most effective one. This paper focuses on the sex educations in the U.S and Japan and describes their features and effectiveness. Abstinence-only sex education is one kind of sex education in the U.S. It is a program which aims to keep adolescents from becoming pregnant by emphasizing the importance of abstaining until they get married. According to the Henry J. Kaiser Family

Love and Sex in Japan

972 words - 4 pages Author Sonya Ryang in in Chapter Two, Sovereign and Love, in her novel, Love and Sex in Modern Japan, discusses the notorious Sada sex murder in juxtaposition with the infamous Rape of Nanjing. Abe Sada, a Japanese woman, came to notoriety in Prewar Japan when she murdered her lover, Kichizo Ishida and then cut off his genitalia and carried them around her purse. Sada and Ishida had a very physical relationship that experimented with masochism

Sex in Othello and Hamlet

3983 words - 16 pages weak it does not. It shows her deviance in that she "goes against social mores by seeing a young man unchaperoned and without her father's approval"(Pitt 53). Hamlet sees that his only way to conquer her exuding sexual power is to drive her to the point of suicidal insanity. If she is no longer sexually attractive to him, he is no longer weak. The way women are portrayed in their death scene is crucial. In Zeferelli's movie, Ophelia is not

Review of" Chatman, Jennifer A. and O'Reilly, Charles A. 2004. Asymmetric reactions to work group sex diversity among men and women. Academy of Management Journal, 47 (2): 193-208."

1144 words - 5 pages Though scholars have amassed significant body of research on how sex diversity influences various work processes, it's still unclear. (a.Chatman and A.Oreilly, 2004)How do men and women react when they are in different sex composed work group? What's the explanation of this reaction?The author used the deductive strategy in the research and he adopts a positivist epistemological position, we deduce a pure Quantitative methodology of article

Sex in the Media

2323 words - 9 pages and young adults about STD's, HIV and AIDS prevention, and teenage pregnancies. In Beyond the Birds and the Bees, Linda R. Clark, Alwyn T. Cohall, Alain Joffe, and Cynthia Starr, researched that "One half of women and three-quarters of men stated that they had sex before they were 18 years old. Nearly 21% of female 12th graders and 25% of male 12th graders report having had four or more sex partners during their lifetime

Similar Essays

Imagery And Allegory In The Seamus Heaney's Poem, The Skunk

612 words - 2 pages Seamus Heaney uses imagery and allegory to enhance the theme of memory in “The Skunk”.  The poem focuses on the image of a skunk and compares a brief image of the speaker's wife preparing for bed. The poem examines the speaker’s longing for his wife while he is away.  Near the end of the poem, the first three stanzas are revealed as having been a scene from the speaker’s memory, when living away from his wife in California. The reader is

A Comparison Of Seamus Heaney's Poem Digging And The Song Of The Old Mother, By William Butler Yeats

1599 words - 6 pages called 'The song of the old mother' written by William Butler Yeats. First of all in Heaney's poem he is talking about himself as a child to his grandfather, while Yeats is talking about the older people to the younger generation. "My grandfather cut more turf in a day, Than any other man in toners bog." This quote shows that Heaney was talking as a child to his grandfather. "And the young lie long and

Sex, Young Adults, And The Media

599 words - 2 pages The media plays a very big role in the lives of young adults today. Whether it is watching Access Hollywood, checking Perez Hilton’s blog religiously or watching fictitious TV shows and movies every night. All of the media in today’s society must add up to some influence on the teens of America. The media today mostly has lust and sex selling us products on television commercials or provocative ads in magazines, or the media just entertains us

Sex Differences And The Degree To Which They Exist In Men And Women

4153 words - 17 pages that increasing trends in female employment has caused a number of studies, economical and otherwise of the workforce. The results showing division is still a major issue even though overall female employment in the work force has increased. -Sex Ratio's: Finds that sex ratios do indeed have an effect on behavior, for example in the 60's and 70's when the women population was in "overflow" we saw a sexual liberalism, lower values on marriage and