This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Mind And The World: Descartes Meditations

1194 words - 5 pages

C. Santos
Professor R. Boeker
The Mind and the World
Due: October 18, 2013

Descartes presents three skeptical arguments in his meditations which shows he has reason to doubt all of his sensory beliefs. Descartes ultimately aims to free himself from all bad beliefs. His quest for certainty is driven from his belief that our belief system is built on a foundation of basic beliefs, that are not justified, in turn, causing him to believe that all his other beliefs are uncertain, as well. His method for achieving a system immune from errors is described in three steps from Meditation One. Descartes three skeptical arguments pose a few objections to the plausibility to each step.
Step one of Meditation One tells us to doubt everything that can be doubted deriving from our senses. Descartes argued that his senses have more than once deceived him, therefore he cannot completely trust his senses. Descartes method to construct an entirely new foundation to set his beliefs on, is called the method of doubt. The method of doubt suggest that in order to find out which beliefs are stable and which are not, we first have to pretend that everything we know is questionable. If Descartes can find any reason for doubt, regarding any of his beliefs, he will withhold assent and this will lead to finding secure foundations of knowledge. We cannot tell when our senses are correctly reporting truth or deceiving us. Just because some of our senses, such as our vision, hearing and touch, are mistaken, that is not reason enough to suspect all of them. The only reason we know that some of our experiences are wrong, is because we are able to realize after the event, that what we thought to be true, is actually wrong. However, Descartes argument seems unreliable when taken into context. To doubt our senses because they occasionally fail us would be like refusing to use safety ropes while climbing because they sometimes fail us.
Step two Descartes three skeptical arguments is called the Dream Argument, where Descartes argues if there is actually a way to distinguish dream from reality. How can one be sure that we are in fact not actually dreaming experiences of the world or that we are dreaming. Our dreams consist of things that we imagine are happening with the same sense of reality as when we actually are awake, making it hard to distinguish what experiences are real and which one of those that are not. With this theory, it is possible to doubt that any physical thing really exists, that there is an external world at all. Our dreams are all bizarre, and without second thought, we don’t even think it could be an illusion. However, when we are dreaming, our sense of the absurd is perfectly working and awake so we do know that what is happening is real. Also, when one is dreaming we experience mental pain, such as anxiety or pain, rather than physical pain. In a dream, you’ll never dream of extreme physical harm as you experience in waking reality...

Find Another Essay On The Mind and the World: Descartes Meditations

Descartes on the Mind and Body

834 words - 4 pages A substance is a philosophical term that defines what a philosopher believes the world to be composed of. Descartes states that the world is composed of two substances: matter and mind. He states that he knows that matter and mind are distinct substances since he can distinctly think of each one separately and since matter is divisible while mind is not. These attempts at proving the distinctness of matter and mind from one another are both

Doubt and the Meditations Essay

1715 words - 7 pages Within Meditations on First Philosophy, Descartes undertakes a worthy goal: the discovery of the sources of doubt with the ultimate result being more truthful opinions, assertions, and arguments. Descartes was well ahead of his times, forging a pathway to more rigorous scholarship through the casting of doubt upon his “opinions”. Unfortunately, however, Descartes was either unable or unwilling to cast doubt upon his primary source of

The Folly of René Descartes’ Discourse on Method and Meditations on First Philosophy

1488 words - 6 pages The Folly of René Descartes’ Discourse on Method and Meditations on First Philosophy In order to embark on his quest for truth, Descartes first devises his four rules which should serve as a solid foundation for all else that he comes to understand. Those rules are here evaluated in terms of what they fail to take into consideration. The rules are examined individually and consecutively, and are therefore also reiterated in order to be

Descartes Philosophy Of The Mind

946 words - 4 pages In the second meditation Descartes wishes to distinguish the mind from the body. However, Descartes recognizes that in order for this to happen he must cast away everything, which he doubts, and find one thing that is absolutely certain. The one thing that Descartes finds to be certain is that he is a thinking thing and he does exist (76,2). He arrives at this conclusion after analyzing a couple different issues. First, Descartes questions the

Criticisms of Descartes Meditations Concerning the Existence of God

2406 words - 10 pages My intent in this essay is to illustrate that the arguments regarding the existence of God and the fear of deception in Descartes’ Meditations on First Philosophy, are quite weak and do not justify his conclusions. To support these claims, I will begin by outlining two specific meditations and explain the proposed arguments. Later, I will critically analyze his arguments, revealing unjust conclusions. Doubts surrounding the text include the

Descartes’ Arguments for the Real Distinction of Mind and Body

1915 words - 8 pages is not really truly separating it as the mind functions as a whole. Descartes also says that as a thinking thing he is “unable to distinguish any parts within myself” (Descartes, Meditations, V!, p59). At first this seems like a very flawed argument as is not everything divisible and surely the mind can be separated into parts as if parts of the brain are damaged does this not damage a part of that person's mind? If one

How did Descartes Explain the Relationship between Mind and Body?

2612 words - 10 pages only with specific ideas and without any knowledge of the external world (Fancher, & Rutherford, 2012). Thus, each one constitute so that human beings are able to operate normally, otherwise none of them would able to exist (Radner, 1971; Fancher, & Rutherford, 2012). So, Descartes was convinced that there is a control centre which control mind-soul and body and lead them to interaction. Logically thinking he started exploring the brain because

The Meditations

926 words - 4 pages example would be that when he speaks of his brother. His stepbrother Verus was very incompetent, but Aurelius could not turn his back on him, because it would go against Nature. Nature is the same thing as Logos. Logos is a force that governs the universe. It is also known as World Reason, Cosmic Mind, God, Zeus, Nature, Providence, Cosmic Meaning, and Fate. He mentions several of these throughout the document. Aurelius states that Providence is the

Descartes' Second and Sixth and Meditations

1183 words - 5 pages Throughout Descartes second and sixth meditations there seems to be a tension rising between the fact of whether or not the mind and body are distinct. By analyzing both meditations it appears that Descartes’ perspectives are contradictory of each other and need to be further evaluated in order to reveal his true meaning. By saying, in the second meditation, that we perceive things by means of our intellect alone, and in the sixth meditation

Descartes - Mind and Body

2270 words - 9 pages Descartes overall objective in the Meditations is to question knowledge. To explore such issues as the existence of God and the separation of mind and body, it was important for him to distinguish what we can know as truth. He believed that reason as opposed to experience was the source for discovering what is of absolute certainty. The first meditation acts as a foundation for all those that follow. Here Descartes discerns between mere opinion

The mind-body relation at descartes

2861 words - 11 pages , le lipșeste puterea argumentativă pentru a clarifica această problemă. 8Bibliografie:Descartes, Rene. Meditații metafizice. Editura Crater, București, 1993. (trad. Ion Papuc)The philosophical writings of Descartes. Volume 2. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1984. (translated by John Cottingham, Robert Stoothhoff, Dulagd Murdoch).Baird, F. and Kaufmann, W. (ed.), Modern Philosophy, Prentice Hall, 2008Clatterbaugh, K. The Causal Debate in Modern Philosophy 1637-1739, Routledge, 1996Cottingham, J. The rationalist. Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1998

Similar Essays

The Mind Body Problem In Descartes Meditations

1402 words - 6 pages to be sure that we are not deceived when we perceive things clearly and distinctly. In the rest of the meditations, Descartes tries to prove that he himself is a thinking being and also that the mind is separate from the body.In Descartes' first meditation, he goes on to prove that nothing exists meaning that because some of our beliefs are based on false pretenses. He establishes that knowledge is built upon a foundation of lesser and simpler

Descartes And The Mind Essay

1105 words - 5 pages Descartes and the mind The topic of the mind and how do we know has been around since the beginning of time. It is one of those questions that will most likely never be answered. I mean, the mind itself is so perplexing that we are still learning stuff about it daily. One question that Descartes proposed was “how do we know?” we still are pondering this one today. We ask it almost every day, maybe not in that way but in some form or another

The Meditations Of Rene Descartes Essay

700 words - 3 pages good. His First Meditation will end with Descartes seemingly troubled over the nature of God. The meditations continue with his questioning of almost everything important to existence. Rene seemed unable to admit anything as truthful. The mind is something of great weakness and error, Descartes would say. He would continue and urge us not to trust what we see because there is no way of being certain about anything. Methodological doubt was

Descartes’ Ultimate Purpose Of The Meditations

1836 words - 7 pages 11). “Descartes has decided that the Augustinian method of knowledge of God and soul is the way to knowledge of the physical world [science]” (Menn 549). I will demonstrate that this initial “ordered” perspective creates serious doubt of the existence of God, while a re-ordering of the Meditations produces a logically sound argument that facilitates an arrival at the intended goal while keeping the arguments intact. First, I