This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Yu Hua, To Live (A Novel) What Does Yu’s Story Of One (Fictional) Man Tell You About The Second Half Of The 20th Century That Spence’s Textbook Does Not, Or Cannot?

832 words - 3 pages

Witnesses and HistoriansChu WangProfessor Lipman04/27/10Witnesses and HistoriansWitnesses and historians are the two distinctive groups of people in recording important historical moments. Witnesses observe history by living through it. Historians observe history by gathering and analyzing witnesses' accounts. Yet the major difference between witnesses and historians is the knowledge of what happened afterwards. Historians know more about the aftermath, and this awareness changes their view of what went before. Witnesses, on contrary, have a comparative advantage here: at a given historical moment, they do not know about the future. Thus their account seems less meticulous or anticipated but more natural and realistic.Acknowledging the difference between witnesses and historians is crucial in analyzing the books written by Yu Hua and Spence. To Live, written by Yu Hua, is a fiction based on near real historical models in 20th century China. Although fictional, the story strikes readers deeply. When reading the story, readers share the sense of worrying the future with the witness, Fu Gui. The unawareness and fear, contrast to historians whose accounts are well structured according to the order of results and consequences, bring readers unexpected resonance in understanding humanity. The chaos, confusion, paradox, perplexity and dark humor that rose up in Fu Gui's life is portrayed by a collective account of many Chinese witnesses during the second half of 20th century. These vivid experiences allow readers to relate to the characters. Every witness who went through this particular historical period shared memories and feelings with Fu Gui. The novel contains an unexpected first-hand account textbooks can not provide. Comparatively, the textbook written by Spence rarely achieves such resonance. At such expense, Spence avoids the partiality and bias in various accounts of witnesses, and constructs a history with order and reason.The amazing part of To Live, as a narration by witnesses, is that sometimes a glance, a shrug, a chance remark, is more revealing than a hundred speeches. In another words, witnesses like Fu Gui and his fellows see things historians can not find in any document. Both books describe what happened in Civil War, when Chiang Kai-shek assigned "non-Manchurians to key posts…in Heilongjiang, Jilin and Liaoning" (Spence 495). Many officials he assigned "abused their powers" (Spence 495) and forced random people from the streets into troops. Yet the historical description stopped here, providing only a general frame of Civil War. Yu's novel actively adds detailed images, psychological activities, and...

Find Another Essay On Yu Hua, To Live (a novel) What does Yu’s story of one (fictional) man tell you about the second half of the 20th century that Spence’s textbook does not, or cannot?

To Live or Not to Live: That is the Question

1803 words - 7 pages other person. This man has been given no opportunities to experience such things with his lack of money to travel or see the world and has no reason to believe that he will ever have these opportunities. In light of this man's situation and no belief in a higher reality, what is his reason to live? His presence on earth ultimately means nothing and living is not worthwhile. It would be ridiculous for this man to live. Klemke, on the other

Does Dr Who tell us about science and technology or the Britain of its time? Discuss

2629 words - 11 pages Does Dr Who tell us about science and technology or the Britain of its time? Discuss. Introduction Doctor Who has been one of the most successful TV series of all time. Produced by the BBC, it describes adventures of a time-traveling humanoid alien, the Doctor, who, in his spaceship TARDIS, encounters different times, places and parts of the universe (Leach, 2009). The series, aired from 1963 until the present day, is a science fiction drama

Does Dr Who tell us about science and technology or the Britain of its time? Discuss

2489 words - 10 pages , people who were around that time were able to experience or at least know what had happened and can’t forget it. “The Day of The Doctor” (2013) episode somewhat shows a similar way as to how it could have happened when the Daleks invaded Gallifrey. As we have all heard or read about World War II, Doctor Who gives us a small insight to a World War III, if one was to happen. In this episode, the Master who sets up a newly built office in 10 Downing

Painting in the Second Half of the Nineteenth Century

1587 words - 6 pages Painting in the Second Half of the Nineteenth CenturyDuring the second half of the nineteenth century, the ideal of self-determinationfostered by the French Revolution and spread by Napoleon helped spawn a revolutionaryspirit across Europe. This spirit of rebellion also infected artists of the period. Paintersbegan to challenge the philosophy and the aesthetic principles of the academies, lookingoutside these conservative institutions for their

To Live or Not to Live, That is the Question

1158 words - 5 pages To Live, Or Not To Live: That Is The Question Terminal illnesses affect many people every year. Some patients simply cannot bear the pain. In 1994, Oregon passed the Death With Dignity Act (DWDA) which authorized physicians to prescribe lethal doses of controlled substances to terminally ill patients with only 6 months to live; this is referred to as physician assisted suicide. The DWDA consists of a list of procedures that a patient must

What sort of man is Walton? 1) Does he serve any thematic function in the novel or is he included largely as a ‘storyteller’.  That is, is he inc

896 words - 4 pages ‘Frankenstein’ or ‘The Modern Prometheus‘ is a 19th century gothic novel written by Mary Shelley. Shelley’s interest in the physical sciences had led her to writing a novel that is based on creating human life in an unnatural way. Victor is one if the narrators who has an unnatural obsession with the sciences led him to discover the secret of life; creating the abomination that is his monster. Walton serves as the neutral narrator that has no

In the Australian Book, 'A Cage of Butterflies', what does the author, Brian Caswell, want to tell the reader about Being Different?

754 words - 3 pages In the novel, A Cage of Butterflies, by Brian Caswell, he explores many themes, the most important being the theme of 'being different. I believe that Brian Caswell is very passionate about this topic and that he wants to explore what being different and an individual really means. This topic is very relevant in today's society.Being drastically different is a burden because you will never be or feel accepted. Many of the kids at the Think-Tank

Wuthering heights: What do we learn about Hindley in the first half of the novel? What do you think about his character and role in the whole novel?

3125 words - 13 pages Wuthering Heights Essay.I)What do you learn about the character of Hindley in these pages and how is he presented.II) Some readers see Hindley as an odd mixture of strength and weakness, of femininity and masculinity. What do you think about his character and role in the whole novel?Hindley is a pivotal character in Wuthering heights and features throughout the novel revealing a number of different aspects to his character. Initially presented

What Message Does The Novel, To Kill A Mockingbird, Convey About Prejudice?

1756 words - 7 pages What Message Does The Novel, To Kill A Mockingbird, Convey About Prejudice?'To Kill a Mockingbird' was set in Alabama during the thirties and wrote the novel in the sixties when Civil Rights Movement was being written. The message of the novel is that people should not be judged according to who/what they are but should be judged on their actions and behaviours. Harper Lee shows prejudice in events like Tom Robinson's trial, also through

Kate Chopin and the Cult of True Womanhood. Brief essay in response to "What does Kate Chopin's 'The Storm' tell us about gender roles in the late 19th century?

1071 words - 4 pages greatest support of this notion is that she does receive help waging the storm, though perhaps not in the purest form.Calixta enters the story performing a domestic task that demands her entire attention. Consequently, the approaching storm goes unnoticed. Yet, when she finally gives the storm attention, she fears not for her own safety, but for the safety of her husband's trousers. At this point, Alcee Laballiere entered the story accompanied

Relates to "To Kill a Mockingbird," by Harper Lee. Discusses the theme of "Racism in the First Half of the 20th Century"

897 words - 4 pages poking the bear for a new generation.Even though slavery was abolished, the epicentre of the problem remained down in the Southern United States (and I'm not referring to the ending of Easy Rider.) The flawed paradigm of black inferiority remained. Writing on the history of slavery in the first half of the twentieth century asserted that blacks were inferior to whites, that races should be separated, and that therefore slavery was not so bad

Similar Essays

How Does Kafka Comment On 20th Century Capitalism Throughout The Novel And What Symbolism Does He Use To Depict It

1931 words - 8 pages How does Kafka Comment on 20th Century Capitalism Throughout the Novel and what Symbolism does he Use to Depict it Firstly, it is important to point out that I don’t believe that the individual characters symbolize a certain social or political group in the novel - the characters’ actions and responses to each other in the in the novel do though, representing a social or political group in a specific situation. For example, the majority

Tell The Story Of A Person Or Animal In Your Life That Annoys You But You Still Care About

742 words - 3 pages When I was ten my parents finally broke down and got me a dog. We had had one before, but it had a problem locating the acceptable areas to mark its territory, and my little sister was just starting to crawl. Not a good combination. Now she was finally capable of discerning what was edible.We got a one year old golden retriever from a friend who was allergic to it. His name was Gideon. The first day we met him, he took a liking to me; he chased

What Does The Novel "Wise Children" Have To Tell Us About Paternity And Maternity?

802 words - 3 pages Melchior accepts them as his children in the last chapter of the novel. "'It's a wise child that knows its own father...But wiser yet the father that knows his own child'" are Perry's wise words of advice to Melchior on taking up on their responsibility.An important lesson is learnt by Dora and Nora as they are given a tremendous birthday present from Perry: the twins of Gareth, another absent father where women are left with the responsibility of their hands. Nora declares that "'they'll both be wise children, all right"', as they are going to tell them the truth of their parents.

Describe A Manager That You Worked For That Does Not Exhibit The Qualities Of A Leader

974 words - 4 pages valuable time, energy and resources to trying to predict and portray what those of which they curie favor want to hear. Stephen Covey (2005) also would agree that when a manager is extremely technical in planning and organizing others it might create ''an atmosphere of doubtfulness'' as well as confine the followers' developmental skills.Do you think that this manager could become an effective leader? Why or why not?I don't think so- why?Steven