Zero Tolerance Policies. Essay

921 words - 4 pages

Zero tolerance policies, dating back to the mid-1990’s originally targeted issues such as drugs and weapons. Over time, schools have broadened their list of conflicts, punishing more children. These policies in public schools enforce punishment in the form of expulsion or suspension on students in response to certain rule violations. The goal of these policies is to promote the safety of all students and staff, therefore if rules are broken, students are punished without exceptions. I oppose the zero tolerance policy in public schools because of the lack of leniency and rationalization. I believe schools should alter consequences based each individual situation. To support my argument, I will be discussing the issues, consequences and alternatives related to zero tolerance policies.

Concerns: Why zero tolerance is unjust.

The biggest issue with zero tolerance in schools is that these policies treat every individual equally regardless of their age, intent, history of behavior or specific needs. This is dangerous because children can be held responsible for crimes that they had no intention of committing. Everyone is punished severely if they make a mistake, despite not being at fault. For instance, a victim of bullying may be given the same punishment as the bully while trying to fight back in an act of self defense. Under a zero tolerance policy, both the bully and the victim will be punished because violence is impermissible according to the school rules. This shows that there really is no tolerance with violence. Children are punished regardless of the reason why they acted a certain way. Another fault with these policies is that they do not take age into account. In the past, students have been punished severely for behavior that is age appropriate. A young kindergartner is to be punished the same as a highschool student even though they may or may not have the understanding of why they are being punished. For example, in 2008 in Tennessee, 8 students were expelled in a week. The variety of offenses ranged from a kindergartner bringing a toy gun to school to a middle-school student threatening to shoot the principal. (Morin, 2011) Both the students, regardless of their motives and age, were expelled. Morin discusses that these policies do more harm than good and concludes by saying that though the intent for both students was very different, the punishment was the same. In my informed opinion this is unfair and both cases should have been treated differently. The kindergartner bought a toy to class, with no intention of hurting anyone. The school officials should have been more lenient with this student, versus the middle-school intent who verbally threatened to harm his principal.

Since zero tolerance policies seek to punish all students who violate school policies, children with special needs are no exception. Even though accommodations exist for these...

Find Another Essay On Zero tolerance policies.

Zero Tolerance Essay

1424 words - 6 pages common in the era of zero tolerance policies within schools. Unfortunately, these harsh disciplinary policies are ineffective and create a school-to-prison pipeline that disproportionately affects minority students and students with disabilities. The concept of zero tolerance, where individuals are punished regardless of the severity of their offense, surfaced in the 1980s in an attempt to curb increasing violent incidents related to gangs and

Bullying: A Problem Legislation Cannot Solve

1228 words - 5 pages students are physically bullied and over half (59%) are verbally bullied. Though a clear definition of bullying exists, a single solution to the problem does not, and there exists interventions that have been shown to be ineffective only after widespread implementation. The importance of zero tolerance policies in highlighting the risks inherent when adopting a solution to a problem without careful examination cannot be stressed enough due to

Zero Tolerance in Schools

1091 words - 4 pages Contemporary Issue Paper Zero tolerance has become the latest contemporary educational issue for the Christian school leader. Zero tolerance policies mandate predetermined consequences for specific offenses. According to a government study, more than three quarters of all U.S. schools reported having zero tolerance policies (Holloway, 2002). Systematic guidelines of enforcing zero tolerance require educational leaders to impose a predetermined

Research on School Policies and Its Conne ction to the Juvenil Courts

637 words - 3 pages The article reviewed serves as a compliment to the research on school policies and its connection to the juvenile court, and how the school-to-prison pipeline has been created. The research article is “Education or Incarceration: Zero Tolerance Policies and the School to Prison Pipeline”. The theme focuses on the flourishing trend in public schools across America that criminalizes students’ minor disciplinary issues as a part of the emerging

This is a short essay discussing the concept of zero tolerance in High school

2780 words - 11 pages . These are all major distractions for the students that are trying to receive an education. Zero tolerance policy attempts eliminate these distractions by temporarily or permanently removing the other students that are causing or possessing one or many of these distractions. '"Could it be argued, however, that despite the negative consequences for those students who cause trouble in schools, zero tolerance policies ultimately rid schools of those

The Harm of Zero Tolerance

939 words - 4 pages acts. Their solution was passed in 1994 as an amendment to the Improving America's Schools Act of 1965, which mandated zero tolerance gun policies with a one year expulsion for offending students. As these policies rolled out opposition rose about how unfair and harmful these new rules were to children. Because of a lack of effectiveness, and the emotional harm that they cause it is clear that these policies must be torn apart and rebuilt upon a

The Juvenile Justice School To Prison Pipeline

760 words - 4 pages Introduction In the most recent years, the relationship between educational institutions and the juvenile justice system which was once created to protect children, has displayed an ultimatum for minors through “zero tolerance” policies which results in sending individuals through the school to prison to pipeline. Studies have shown that these zero tolerance policies are not beneficial to students or the educational environment that should be

Zero Tolerance

983 words - 4 pages nation introduced the zero-tolerance policies aimed at the curtailment of harmful student behaviors” (Noll, 2014, p. 295). The original focus of the policies was to eliminate the use/carrying of weapons but soon after spread to restricting drugs and medication (2014). By 2006 95% of the U.S. public schools had adopted the zero-tolerance policies and more than half of them reported taking significant action against students, many of which resulted

To Discipline or Not Discipline

791 words - 4 pages School policies continue to change with the times as decreed by the government. Sometimes the change is beneficial for all and not just a few students. Associate professor and director of at University of New Hampshire School of Law, Leah A. Plunkett in her web article, “Punishing Students for Gadget Use Will Make Their Tech Etiquette Worse,” defends the presidential administration policy to drop the “zero tolerance” policy in schools. (1

No Tolerance

1311 words - 5 pages The issue of school safety is a concern shared between teachers, students, parents, administration and the community. Providing a safe and proactive school action plan is essential to an effective and excelling education for every student. This plan must include alternatives to the zero tolerance policies set forth by the adoption of the Gun Free Schools Act of 1994. Through the effective use of this policy the Union Colony Charter School will

Resortive Justice to Discipline Students

1971 words - 8 pages affecting the community. Restorative justice is still very new and requires more time to pass before its effect on students can be seen, be it good or bad. Works Cited Daniels, Peggy. Zero tolerance policies in schools. Detroit: Greenhaven P, 2009. Davis, Fania. "Discipline with Dignity: Oakland schools try talk circles." 5 March 2014. The Christian Science Monitor . Magazine Article . 5 March 2014. Graham, Kristen A. "Report says zero-tolerance

Similar Essays

Zero Tolerance Policies In American Schools

1172 words - 5 pages In all grades of education, from kindergarten to college, there is a form of discipline known as a zero tolerance policy. While the exact wording is different from school to school, basically a zero tolerance policy means that a student is immediately suspended, asked to attend an alternative school, or expelled if they are suspected or caught doing certain things. These policies are in place to hopefully deter students from doing drugs or being

The Impact Of Zero Tolerance Policies

1513 words - 7 pages The zero tolerance policies that date back to the mid-1990’s originally targeted issues such as drugs and weapons. Over time, schools have broadened their list of punishable offenses, creating more disciplinary issues. These policies in public schools enforce punishment, in the form of expulsion or suspension, on students in response to certain rule violations. The goal of these policies is to promote the safety of all students and staff. If

Zero Tolerance Policies Are An Issue Widely Debated Today, It

1361 words - 5 pages Zero tolerance policies are an issue widely debated today, it seems like neither side is breaking away from the pack. Zero tolerance policies institute no case-by-case evaluations, but they stipulate that there is only one final solution for any number of problems. The zero tolerance policies were instituted to eliminate any discretion between cases. They were also put in place to scare students into obeying the rules before they break

Schools Should Eliminate The Use Of Zero Tolerance Policies

957 words - 4 pages reasons for this; most of these explanations do not place the blame squarely on the schools themselves. Public schools are responsible for one thing, however, and that is the manner in which they react to the changes that take place. Prompted by increased discipline problems within school halls, many districts have adopted zero-tolerance policies toward certain problems, including drugs and violence. When considering current events such as